After watching the film and now seeing your comment, all I can do is chuckle lol.
Haha, ok, just spoil it, that way I know if I should pay to watch it or wait until it's free. Do they end up together or do they just end up as friends?
So, no shade to Thai BLs, because I have watched them all and enjoyed them, but most of them feel like student productions, with mediocre supporting actors. poor plotting, sound and lighting issues, and low budgets. We love and support the shows anyway of course, because we love to watch and see cute guys fall in love. But this drama actually feels like a real television show. I guess after the success of 2gether, GMMTV has realized they can actually make some money if they invest some real money into a quality production. For example, the parents in this drama are actually good actors, Tian's mom in particular. There was a large variety of sets, aerial shots. Even the intro was cute and looked like real thought had been put into it. I am really impressed. Between this show and KinnPorsche (or at least, based on the trailer), it seems like BLs are getting more respect and more investment and I am 100% here for it. I hope the writing stays strong through to the end. This was a great first episode!
I already have a feeling this is going to be one big queerbaiting. I will be happily surprised if I am wrong. But I feel like they will just end up being friends in the end.
I have no idea what happened in this show. It seemed like they made about 4 episodes and then realized they were going to run out of time, so they tried to squeeze about 10 more episodes into the last 4, and it turned in a one long montage without any time to experience what was happening.
I think they should have just made this a 5-6 minute long music video. The song at the end was the best part.
I liked that it was short and they didn't pad out the length by inventing ridiculous and clichéd drama. The two leads were cute and I liked that they were both super into each other, no crying over being into guys, the friends were fun and Key's ex-girlfriend is absolutely beautiful. The song at the end of the finale was good, I already found a new Filipino musical artist to listen to. I thought the voice overs at the end were a little long, but I get that they needed to give the show a "moral" which I guess was, don't let coronavirus get you down? Hopefully, this studio makes more series, I would def. watch.
You know, the songs are not bad! I grew up with 90s boybands, and the songs from this series could fit right in! Danny and Aiden are cute, I enjoyed it!
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
well, as a person in a sexual minority, I guess it's nice to know that, based on your definition of constructive criticism, my opinion doesn't matter. Anyway, I think we can leave it there. Good luck.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
From Lintz: t hat's just disgusting. PLEASE, give us shows with actual, realistic queer representation where not everyone is gay and/ or homophobic. I'm so tired of these plots. I am so glad that there have been some Pinoy web series this year that have legit queer representation and they battle real problems us queer people face.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
from bigohfan: The fact that some people find this show offensive makes me laugh. Stop taking everything so seriously. This show is meant to be fun! Please relax and enjoy the show :)
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
from doodles 21: @ koala_effect : I’m with you. I think some people cannot grasp the concept of a comedic fun ride and I guess to each his own. But I do wish they would stop calling those of us who like it, names. In its own way - that too is prejudicial, expecting everyone to think the same and if we don’t - calling us names. Live and let live dudes and dudettes! Let those of us who love it - love it and move on if you don’t
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
from jpny01: I don't find this funny in the slightest. I guess if you think misogyny and forcing people to have sex with prostitutes against their will is funny.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
From karandeep singh, about 10 comments down: Is it only me who is pissed at Ton for literally for forcing Chon to hv sex with a hooker. I hate his toxic masculinity. It was so uncomfortable to watch. I think its more to do with his upbringing.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
It seems like the root of our disagreement is the term "constructive criticism". I disagree that constructive criticism is "logical and objective." If I say to someone at my job, "when you spoke to me in that way, it made me feel this negative way, please don't speak to me in that way again." That is constructive criticism. Or, on a larger scale, if my boss said to me, "When you are talking in meetings, your coworkers have told me that they feel talked down to or belittled, please change the way your are talking to them," that also is constructive criticism. If someone in a comment section says, "this trope or character type makes me feel this negative way, I wish that shows wouldn't include these tropes in their shows anymore because it makes me feel bad, " that is constructive criticism. I have provided lots of examples of people having their feelings shut down by Toxic Positivity. I didn't find an article that was specifically about Toxic Positivity in the comment sections of websites devoted to Asian drams and BL Dramas, but that is a little specific and I doubt it has been an area of study yet (although maybe it should be). That is why I spent so much time explaining my argument, so that it would be clear that I am equating criticism and feelings, as I mentioned previously. If you are holding out for a peer-reviewed research study about BL drama message boards, I don't think it's going to happen.
You said in your previous post "if you said how you felt about the show, and someone told you not to be so negative, then yes, that can be considered toxic positivity. You're just stating how you feel, and that shouldn't be invalidated by others. But that's not what you were talking about in your original comment. You mentioned 'legitimate criticism' and 'constructive criticism.'
Now I feel like we have been talking about two completely different things this entire time. I have been talking about the criticism that people in these comments have been making about the way that these tropes make them feel (specifically, the "have sex with a woman sex worker to prove you are straight). Since I have mentioned this specific example multiple times, I thought it would be understand that when I am talking about constructive criticism, I am specifically talking about this example: Commenters have said they didn't like the show because this scene reminded them of times in their own lives when people tried to do this to them (encourage or outright force them to sleep with a woman to prove their heterosexuality). I'm definitely not talking about the lighting. I agree that saying that technical aspects of the show are not good and having others tell you not to focus on it is probably not toxic positivity, but that is not what I have been talking about for the last day.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
Credentials don't matter on the internet because anyone can claim anything and there is no way to prove it (at least not in a comment section). I think the issue is that you are arguing for a completely literalist interpretation of the term "Toxic Positivity." You know one specific definition and no other definition or interpretation that is not *exactly the same* is valid.
I have been listening to you and will continue to listen to you, I just disagree with you. And you still haven't addressed the merits of my argument, you just keep repeating that what I have said is not exactly the same as your understanding.
If I said, "I feel bad when I watch this series because it reminds me of when someone told me to go have sex with a woman to prove to everyone I am a manly, straight man even though I am a gay man" and then someone responded, "Oh, just look on the bright side! The show has some funny comedic scenes! No need to be so negative about it." By the way, I didn't make this up. Read down through the comments and you will see very similar comments.
Again, I am talking about similarities and comparisons. Not things that are exactly, 100% the same in every way. You seem to be arguing that this *criticism* is somehow fundamentally different from a *feeling*. And I think that is where we disagree. If my criticism of the show is based in how I feel when I watch the show, and you tell me to just be positive and ignore my feelings, I feel that this almost perfectly matches the definition of Toxic Positivity that we have both been discussing.
If you disagree, please explain why. What is the fundamental difference between a criticism of a show that is based in the feelings of the viewer and just a regular old feeling?
If you tell me to ignore my negative feelings about the show and only talk about the positive aspects of the show, how is that not Toxic Positivity.
I have explained my argument multiple times, and you have refused to engage with it at all, other than repeating the same definition multiple times. I argue there is no fundamental difference between a criticism of the show that is based in how it makes the viewer feel and, as you have continuously repeated, a "feeling". These criticisms *are* feelings.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
I hear what you are saying, but the problem is that you are not offering constructive criticism. You are simply saying my definition of the term is wrong, because you know a different definition. I *have* looked up the term, I have *also* studied psychology and sociology, and I agreed with you about 3 comments ago that the definition you gave is a correct definition. So I don't think there is anything left to say on that topic.
However, you telling me that my definition is wrong "because I heard it in a TV show" is extremely elitist and, to use your word from a few comments ago, dismissive. As I mentioned before, the definitions of things changes over time (a phenomenon known as semantic change) and it happens especially quickly on the internet. If you would like more information on this topic, feel free to reach out and I will be happy to send you an article or two. As for me 'knowing' better, I typed several comments with a detailed explanation of my argument for why the term Toxic Positivity applies here. You have not addressed the merits of those arguments at all in your comments, instead you have simply chosen to apply several different terms in place of toxic positivity: Dismissive and narcissistic being two of those terms. Narcissistic also has a specific meaning in psychology (see narcissistic personality disorder) so I think it's interesting that you have chosen to use the casual definition (a person who thinks only of themselves to a high degree) rather than the clinical definition, which you are trying to force me to use for Toxic Positivity. You used the word hypocritical before, so I will use it here. Don't you think it's hypocritical to attempt to reject my colloquial use of the term Toxic Positivity and then do exactly the same thing with the term "narcissistic"?
Anyway, I always know when people are feeling pressed in arguments on the internet. It's when they rely on an appeal to expertise. "I have studied this, so I know." I don't know you. Maybe you have a PhD in psychology or maybe you learned everything on YouTube. Who cares? If your argument is strong, it's strong, and if your argument is weak, it's weak. Your credentials don't mean anything here. I have credentials too, but I'm not going to share them, because ultimately, they don't matter. Also, people lie on the internet all the time. I am not saying you are lying, but you are a faceless bubble on kisskh. I don't know you, so I am definitely not going to take your word for it.
Finally, here is a source that defines Toxic Positivity in this way: ' "We can see toxic positivity on social media when people share content about life's challenges and the only replies are overly positive and ignore that that person might be feeling upset, tired, worried and so on," she says.
It might also be a post that is dismissive of hard times in our current climate, for example.'
You will notice that the author uses the term "dismissive" as a synonym for Toxic Positivity.
This is not a rigorous academic source, but it doesn't need to be. It is evidence that people are using the term, both as you defined it, but also as I defined it.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
I see it used in exactly the way you described in the internet all the time but I also see it used in the way I described. The meaning of words changes over time, of course. It seems that maybe the definition of Toxic Positivity has changed from the definition you are used to. I believe, based on the examples that I gave, that Toxic Positivity is the best term to describe what is happening here. Your argument is not really an argument. You are just saying my usage of the term is wrong because it means something else to you. Words can mean more than one thing at once. Telling other people that they are not allowed to be critical ("negative") about a show meets the definition of Toxic Positivity. Also, I'm not sure why you are so invested in arguing against this usage of the term. I mean, it seems straightforward to me. "No hate, only love", "no criticism, just praise", these are clear examples of a focus on the positive at the expense of the justified negative, also known as Toxic Positivity.
I just wanted to let you know that that isn't what toxic positivity is. Toxic positivity is where you force yourself…
I agree that what you described sounds bad, but Toxic Positivity as the term is used today on the internet is when *someone else* tells you to "look on the bright side" even though that means ignoring a real issue that is causing problems. For example, telling someone with a mental illness to "just look at the positive, go outside and get some sun, you will feel better, there is so much beauty in the world, no reason to be depressed!"
So, using that definition, I definitely think telling someone, "this series is meant to be fun, don't take it so seriously, only love, no hate or negativity" counts as Toxic Positivity.
I liked it, it was pretty middle-of-the-road as far as Thai BLs go. The plot lagged a lot in the middle, I think they could have done this just fine in about 8 episodes instead of 12. Itt was super cute, I agree with other commenters that Pai was kind of personality-less for much of the series. I get that sometimes people put up a wall and are guarded, but if he is the main character, it would have been nice if the directors had let the audience more into his head, instead of him just walking around with a tortured expression on his face all the time.
Pure was the winner of this series for me. I loved his character (so cute!). I liked that his character arc was that he was heartbroken and so he followed his mom's example of sleeping around, but then he got over it and moved on and started a healthier relationship with Folk. Not that casual sex is unhealthy, but it definitely seemed like Pure made some bad decisions. I also love that he got tested for STIs 2x in the show! A good example for the viewers! Get tested!
Overall, I gave it a very a generous 8.5, because it was still much better than a lot of other Thai BLs (for example, it was better than Oxygen by a huge amount). But still, nowhere near the level of I Told Sunset About You.
I think they should have just made this a 5-6 minute long music video. The song at the end was the best part.
Live and let live dudes and dudettes! Let those of us who love it - love it and move on if you don’t
You said in your previous post "if you said how you felt about the show, and someone told you not to be so negative, then yes, that can be considered toxic positivity. You're just stating how you feel, and that shouldn't be invalidated by others. But that's not what you were talking about in your original comment. You mentioned 'legitimate criticism' and 'constructive criticism.'
Now I feel like we have been talking about two completely different things this entire time. I have been talking about the criticism that people in these comments have been making about the way that these tropes make them feel (specifically, the "have sex with a woman sex worker to prove you are straight). Since I have mentioned this specific example multiple times, I thought it would be understand that when I am talking about constructive criticism, I am specifically talking about this example: Commenters have said they didn't like the show because this scene reminded them of times in their own lives when people tried to do this to them (encourage or outright force them to sleep with a woman to prove their heterosexuality). I'm definitely not talking about the lighting. I agree that saying that technical aspects of the show are not good and having others tell you not to focus on it is probably not toxic positivity, but that is not what I have been talking about for the last day.
I have been listening to you and will continue to listen to you, I just disagree with you. And you still haven't addressed the merits of my argument, you just keep repeating that what I have said is not exactly the same as your understanding.
If I said, "I feel bad when I watch this series because it reminds me of when someone told me to go have sex with a woman to prove to everyone I am a manly, straight man even though I am a gay man" and then someone responded, "Oh, just look on the bright side! The show has some funny comedic scenes! No need to be so negative about it." By the way, I didn't make this up. Read down through the comments and you will see very similar comments.
Again, I am talking about similarities and comparisons. Not things that are exactly, 100% the same in every way. You seem to be arguing that this *criticism* is somehow fundamentally different from a *feeling*. And I think that is where we disagree. If my criticism of the show is based in how I feel when I watch the show, and you tell me to just be positive and ignore my feelings, I feel that this almost perfectly matches the definition of Toxic Positivity that we have both been discussing.
If you disagree, please explain why. What is the fundamental difference between a criticism of a show that is based in the feelings of the viewer and just a regular old feeling?
If you tell me to ignore my negative feelings about the show and only talk about the positive aspects of the show, how is that not Toxic Positivity.
I have explained my argument multiple times, and you have refused to engage with it at all, other than repeating the same definition multiple times. I argue there is no fundamental difference between a criticism of the show that is based in how it makes the viewer feel and, as you have continuously repeated, a "feeling". These criticisms *are* feelings.
However, you telling me that my definition is wrong "because I heard it in a TV show" is extremely elitist and, to use your word from a few comments ago, dismissive. As I mentioned before, the definitions of things changes over time (a phenomenon known as semantic change) and it happens especially quickly on the internet. If you would like more information on this topic, feel free to reach out and I will be happy to send you an article or two. As for me 'knowing' better, I typed several comments with a detailed explanation of my argument for why the term Toxic Positivity applies here. You have not addressed the merits of those arguments at all in your comments, instead you have simply chosen to apply several different terms in place of toxic positivity: Dismissive and narcissistic being two of those terms. Narcissistic also has a specific meaning in psychology (see narcissistic personality disorder) so I think it's interesting that you have chosen to use the casual definition (a person who thinks only of themselves to a high degree) rather than the clinical definition, which you are trying to force me to use for Toxic Positivity. You used the word hypocritical before, so I will use it here. Don't you think it's hypocritical to attempt to reject my colloquial use of the term Toxic Positivity and then do exactly the same thing with the term "narcissistic"?
Anyway, I always know when people are feeling pressed in arguments on the internet. It's when they rely on an appeal to expertise. "I have studied this, so I know." I don't know you. Maybe you have a PhD in psychology or maybe you learned everything on YouTube. Who cares? If your argument is strong, it's strong, and if your argument is weak, it's weak. Your credentials don't mean anything here. I have credentials too, but I'm not going to share them, because ultimately, they don't matter. Also, people lie on the internet all the time. I am not saying you are lying, but you are a faceless bubble on kisskh. I don't know you, so I am definitely not going to take your word for it.
Finally, here is a source that defines Toxic Positivity in this way: ' "We can see toxic positivity on social media when people share content about life's challenges and the only replies are overly positive and ignore that that person might be feeling upset, tired, worried and so on," she says.
It might also be a post that is dismissive of hard times in our current climate, for example.'
You will notice that the author uses the term "dismissive" as a synonym for Toxic Positivity.
https://www.abc.net.au/life/toxic-positivity-on-social-media-and-how-to-avoid-it/12432790
This is not a rigorous academic source, but it doesn't need to be. It is evidence that people are using the term, both as you defined it, but also as I defined it.
So, using that definition, I definitely think telling someone, "this series is meant to be fun, don't take it so seriously, only love, no hate or negativity" counts as Toxic Positivity.
Pure was the winner of this series for me. I loved his character (so cute!). I liked that his character arc was that he was heartbroken and so he followed his mom's example of sleeping around, but then he got over it and moved on and started a healthier relationship with Folk. Not that casual sex is unhealthy, but it definitely seemed like Pure made some bad decisions. I also love that he got tested for STIs 2x in the show! A good example for the viewers! Get tested!
Overall, I gave it a very a generous 8.5, because it was still much better than a lot of other Thai BLs (for example, it was better than Oxygen by a huge amount). But still, nowhere near the level of I Told Sunset About You.