Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 22 hours ago
  • Location: Texas, USA
  • Contribution Points: 0 LV0
  • Roles:
  • Join Date: August 31, 2019
On Tonhon Chonlatee • Nov 23, 2020
Is anyone watching Pearl Next Door, the spin-off from Gameboys? Because Pearl introduced a term that I think a lot of people in this comment section need to learn: Toxic Positivity. It's when people use "positivity" as a weapon to shut down other people's legitimate criticism. "Wow, it's really sad that you just can't take the show for a fun series. You are so negative with all your hate! It's just meant to be lighthearted! You are reading too much into it! If you don't love it, that's your opinion, but do you have to share your negative hate here? That's sad. You should just move on!"

I have read that about 10 times in these comments so far. Here's what I understand it to mean: A person likes the show for whatever reason (hot guys, a particular actor, whatever) and then someone criticizes the show for good reason (a bro pushing his younger bro to have sex with a woman to prove he's a "real man", for example. That's gross). The person who likes the show will say something like, "yeah, I guess that is not great, but why do you have to take it so seriously! It's just meant to be fun. Love only, no hate!" And then the person who criticized the show will respond with another explanation of the critique (pushing queer people to have sex with someone to prove their heterosexuality is a form of corrective rape and has been used to control queer people for a long time, for example), and the person who likes the show will respond, "It's sad that you can't just enjoy it, why are you even here? It's just my opinion, I like it. Some people just can't enjoy things."

And this pattern will continue.

Honestly, Toxic Positivity is bs. It's a derailing technique. It's used to shut down criticism. If you think someone's criticism is invalid, give reasons and support. Basically what Toxic Positivity comes down to is that people know that the show is problematic, and they know the critiques of the show are valid, and they don't care, but they don't want to admit it because then they would have to feel bad for liking something problematic.

If the best response you can come up with is, "only love, no hate, it's just meant to be fun, why do you have to ruin things for others? It's sad that some people can't just enjoy things", then you know the other person's critique is valid and you should own it. Otherwise, you are spreading Toxic Positivity and I hope that people will call you out on it. I will. Critiques are important because they change consciousness and lead to positive (really positive, not Toxically Positive) change, like better representation for queer people.

I think I am just going to copy this comment and paste it under every comment where I see "Toxic Positivity." Feel free to copy it as well.

When people spend time and do emotional labor to explain why things are problematic, listen to them, thank them for their work, and consider that they might be right. That's how we are going to get shows that are "meant to be fun and not serious" but that also don't perpetuate gross and outdated stereotypes.

Feel free to come argue with me if you want. It's sad that some people just can't take constructive criticism. /s ;-)
24 19
Synchonicity • Nov 23, 2020
"too bad it was a dead gay character saying it to a mom that couldn't hear it." we need to move this line to the synopsis of the show so that people can read it before they watch. perfect critique.
1 1
Replying to Not a Robot • Nov 22, 2020
I feel like this is the homophobia version of the "the is your brain on drugs" egg in the skillet PSA. I think…
I agree. How about instead of a "homophobia will kill your kids" series, we get a "homophobia will lead your kids to never speak to you again but go on to live wonderful, successful, love-filled lives and you will regret for the rest of your life that you drove away your child who is completely happy without you" series. And then Ken and Shake say fuck you to Mom and Sandee, move in together, finish college, get decent-paying jobs in this economy, and then when they get married (I know it's not legal, but they can still have a ceremony), they can NOT invite mom because she doesn't deserve it.

I feel like that would be a much better story.
17 1
On Like in the Movies • Nov 20, 2020
People are complaining about the ending, but I'm kind of confused as to why? It seemed perfectly clear to me. Karl isn't ready, Vlad won't settle, time passed, they have moved on but are still open to being friends and maybe re-kindling their relationship in the future. What's confusing about that? It's not a happily ever after but it's real. (like, really real, not like someone dies in a car crash like some other shows I could name cough* MODC*cough).

I loved it. I would enjoy a season 2 but if not, we already saw what their life could be like. I like it when things end in their time and this feels like an ending.

It thought the whole show was beautiful. I see some folks disagree, and your opinion is worthwhile, too. But for me, this is exactly the kind of show I want, with real characters, real relationships, a little silliness because I am silly, great music, love, tears, and something meaningful in the end. For me, the message that love isn't always enough, but that love endures is powerful. They will always love each other and maybe someday the stars will align and they will build a life together. Or maybe they will stay friends and find other loves and always look back on the time they spent together and feel those feelings again for a moment and smile and cry a little. They have good friends, family who love them, skills, goals, careers to look forward to.

I want to see queer people like this, who can love, and fail, and move on, and be whole. That means so much more to me than shows where all that matters is that one guy kisses you in the end.
20 0
Replying to dizzy • Nov 20, 2020
severely underwhelming. tbh i was just forcing myself to get through every ep bc i was simply that bored. a bunch…
Yeah, I agree. Like, My Day was not a good show, but it wasn't boring. This show was just a big meh.
0 0
On Tonhon Chonlatee • Nov 13, 2020
Ahh! This was so cute! I had a good feeling about this one and the first ep was great! Can't wait for more!
3 0
Replying to EllaFaith • Nov 13, 2020
Title Gen Y Spoiler
I’m only watching this for bas cause I feel like he’s story is more interesting
Dumped by P'Pha!!! So sad! haha, I'm living for it. I like Wayu much better than Wayo. Bas is a much better actor now than he was a couple of years ago and this show is much better produced than 2Moons.
1 0
Replying to IslandGirlIslandLife • Nov 13, 2020
Title Gen Y
And the Pink Milk has returned. Pretty okay start. It's SUPER corny. Wayu's little brother is hilarious. If you…
I agree about Mark. He reminds me of this guy I used to hook up with in college, who just started showing up at my place, expecting to hook up (no call, no text). Super irritating. Just cause you like someone, stalking is not okay. Mark is lucky he doesn't get punched. He's cute but not that cute. Like, back off, dude.
3 0
On Gen Y • Nov 13, 2020
Title Gen Y
I actually thought this first episode was pretty good! Aside from the fact there are certain...suspicious similarities, I will say ;-), I was expecting another dumpster fire like Hotel Stars. But this was decent. Basic, but decent.
2 0
On SaifahZon Story • Nov 11, 2020
So, is this like Love by Chance 2? They are basically re-doing SaiZon? I hope we don't get weird continuity issues like in LBC2..
0 0
On I'm Tee, Me Too • Nov 11, 2020
I thought the plot was kind of whatever, but since I like all of the actors, it was fun. Better than expected, solid 8.5.
8 0
I thought it was great! Gulf and Mew still have great chemistry, it's not set in college, and they are arguing about normal grown up things. The random side characters thing is, I guess, normal for Mame's stories, but still weird, but oh well, I'm used to it by now. Looking forward to the next episode!
12 0
Replying to TheTaunter • Nov 4, 2020
i suggest you do some research or read the youtube comments after watching every episode.
No? Why would the fact that you had to do research to understand something mean that the show didn't deliver? That's like saying a piece of media has to assume its fans know nothing. Some people have a broader experience, are more well-read, etc.. than others. Just because you didn't get it or understand it doesn't mean it didn't deliver. Media can be complex and require thought, reflection, and yes, research. That is how you learn: something you love has elements beyond your experience and you look for more knowledge because you want to understand the thing you love. It sounds like you want media to be dumbed down so people don't have to work to understand. The work makes the understanding, when it comes, sweeter. Push yourself to grow and learn, don't expect that everything will always be easily within your reach, not even BLs.
0 2