People are just speculating because GYJ's facial expression in the teaser is too soft. Don't ask 🙄 I thought…
The use of the bell makes her running wild situation incomparable to the previous people. They were not hypnotized.
He hypnotized her. Sent her to the cliff. She clearly has no memory of how or why she got there. Or why she was petrifying. So at least a PORTION of her memory IS gone.
If he could hypnotize her after the zombie killing rampage to then go suicide herself he could manipulate her memory as well. The entire point of the hypnosis is we have no idea what he did or didn’t say because part of it is offscreen. I have learned to stop using past situations as examples in current ones because this show makes up new rules, new X factors and nothing can be predicted.
People are just speculating because GYJ's facial expression in the teaser is too soft. Don't ask 🙄 I thought…
Yes I know. But it’s not clear at all from that scene exactly what she remembers or doesn’t. It’s only clear she does not remember that she went on the rampage. It’s not guaranteed she retained all her memories before that. We don’t know what Jin Mu said offscreen. Most people don’t even realize he told her to go suicide herself. He could have said some other dumb s**** messing with her memory as well. As I said I do not think she ends up with amnesia but this show does love to use it as a plot device.
Naksu x Yul never gonna happen. Unless Uk soul shifts into Yul.
Totally agree. Naksu x Yul never happening. I CAN see Jang Uk feeling confused between unfamiliar faced Naksu and familiar faced Jin BY in the sense that he would do everything to protect them both.
One way or another people are going to be unhappy 😅 No JSM, people will be unhappy. A little JSM, people will…
Totally agree. The only problem is you can do certain things in writing with body swaps that work in a book but do not work in a TV Show/Movie. So you don’t just write for the story, you have to write for the medium (tv) that will tell the story.
As you said, Bottom line though is you can’t please all of the people all of the time no matter what!
People are just speculating because GYJ's facial expression in the teaser is too soft. Don't ask 🙄 I thought…
Preface: I don’t get amnesia vibe from the trailer.
But- She’s not going to be the same peaceful person she was talking to Joo Wol with the events that happen after with the knowledge that she killed people including Jung Uk and that it was Jin Mu using her. Her character would be on a vengeance mission against Jin Mu. She would want to kill him ASAP.
She does seem to have lost her memory at the cliff when she doesn’t know why she’s standing there. She only knows she’s petrifying.
I watched the preview many times. Naksu looks very different. She seems in the different state. A lot of fans…
They definitely made a clear and concerted effort to style her *very* differently from not just her OG image but also differently from all the returning players in the trailer. I don’t know if it reads amnesia to me (it could just as easily read someone else is inside her) I won’t speculate the reason but it’s clear. Even her hair and clothing is not typical of what anyone wears in public in the Daeho universe. The simple hair down with the white undercoat/almost nightgown time simple dress. It’s dreamy goddess vibes.
this drama had a lot of flaws to me but still I was rooting for it to hit double ratings cuz I do want this to…
It seems like there is a ceiling for Fantasy drama’s in Korea. This is one of the reasons I wish people were not comparing EAW ratings to AOS ratings. One is meant for easy watching by all ages/families. The other features violence and dark concepts not suited for all audiences. Hopefully this and the second season of Arthdal Chronicles can break through some of that ceiling with their popularity and quality of production/storytelling.
Because they pulled an absurd rabbit out of a hat with the last minute “all soul ejectors are cursed” here’s…
Yes, the “Bell” that can cause any soul shifter to run wild and become a zombie killing machine because of a Shaman curse on the soul ejectors that was never once revealed before (this is Peak Absurdity) “Oh by the way all soul ejectors are cursed by the shaman queen!”
The question of “where was BY” is one we are all asking. Was she just overpowered by Jin Mu when he “activated Naksu’s powers” inside her body? That would be another last minute “Oh By the way if Naksu activates her powers she will start to run wild!” Absurd plot twist that breaks all previous show history.
Since Naksu DID use her powers to kill the soul shifter to save Jang Uk and nothing happened to her then it contradicts the “she can’t use her powers or she’ll petrify” I’m sure they’ll explain it as something to do with the ice stone at that time but it still lacks logic. All soul shifters could use their powers then and they didn’t all have the ice stone inside them.
My theory is Bu Yeons soul was just not there at that time. It went somewhere else after the Ice Stone Fiasco. So she couldn’t stop Jin Mu from activating Naksu’s power. And once Naksu’s power activates, as Master Lee said, this creates a crack and they start to petrify (despite us seeing her use her powers literally one episode earlier with no problems)
Just as this article came out today, last week an article came out that said “Jung So Min DOES NOT appear in Part 2. And they cited double confirmation from a TVN source. So that was why *fans of the show, fans of Mu-Deok, fans of Jin Bu Yeon* not just “JSM fans” reacted. Had multiple articles not been circulated how do you think people would get the idea she doesn’t appear in Part 2. It’s because it was said in an article just like this one.
So you can stay annoyed but you shouldn’t be annoyed at the people posting. You should be annoyed at the reckless articles being written and circulated with conflicting information.
News 
1 
He hypnotized her. Sent her to the cliff. She clearly has no memory of how or why she got there. Or why she was petrifying. So at least a PORTION of her memory IS gone.
If he could hypnotize her after the zombie killing rampage to then go suicide herself he could manipulate her memory as well. The entire point of the hypnosis is we have no idea what he did or didn’t say because part of it is offscreen. I have learned to stop using past situations as examples in current ones because this show makes up new rules, new X factors and nothing can be predicted.
Put your petitions away people 😭
As you said, Bottom line though is you can’t please all of the people all of the time no matter what!
Dude is literally a cat with nine lives and the heaviest of plot armor .
But- She’s not going to be the same peaceful person she was talking to Joo Wol with the events that happen after with the knowledge that she killed people including Jung Uk and that it was Jin Mu using her. Her character would be on a vengeance mission against Jin Mu. She would want to kill him ASAP.
She does seem to have lost her memory at the cliff when she doesn’t know why she’s standing there. She only knows she’s petrifying.
Really hope they don’t go that route though.
Really hoping they don’t go that route.
The question of “where was BY” is one we are all asking. Was she just overpowered by Jin Mu when he “activated Naksu’s powers” inside her body? That would be another last minute “Oh By the way if Naksu activates her powers she will start to run wild!” Absurd plot twist that breaks all previous show history.
Since Naksu DID use her powers to kill the soul shifter to save Jang Uk and nothing happened to her then it contradicts the “she can’t use her powers or she’ll petrify” I’m sure they’ll explain it as something to do with the ice stone at that time but it still lacks logic. All soul shifters could use their powers then and they didn’t all have the ice stone inside them.
My theory is Bu Yeons soul was just not there at that time. It went somewhere else after the Ice Stone Fiasco. So she couldn’t stop Jin Mu from activating Naksu’s power. And once Naksu’s power activates, as Master Lee said, this creates a crack and they start to petrify (despite us seeing her use her powers literally one episode earlier with no problems)
So you can stay annoyed but you shouldn’t be annoyed at the people posting. You should be annoyed at the reckless articles being written and circulated with conflicting information.