This was an okay-ish drama in my opinion despite a high quality production from WOWOW. The plot was a bit unrealistic and writing+directing of the MC could have been done better. If I want to make a comparison with other drama with the same genre from the same season, Touboui F might be 100 times better in terms of the plot than Shoutai. However, I rated both dramas at 7.5....so they are roughly the same in terms of my overall satisfaction.
The premise was interesting, but to be honest I found the plot was bland and boring...I couldn't care less about Kaneko Daichi's character (which was very stereotyped)...it's unfortunate that this boring character has more screen time than Shimobee in this drama...not sure how the manga was like...perhaps the source material wasn't that great to begin with...
To be honest the plot was okay and watchable (although it's predictable and cliche). The only problem for this drama is its production and direction...lol The comedy was a bit hard to laugh at (some were dark comedies) and just came up out of nowhere despite the seriousness tone of the drama...then again the viewers have to deal with the overacting too and bad BGM at the same time...If you can handle these things, you're good to go.
A very well done drama. The best part of the writing was probably on the emotion and human relationship among the characters. The war part was straight of the history book, and viewers who are not familiar with the events might have to do some additional readings to get bigger picture of it.
The action scene during the war was really jaw dropping. It's rare to see something as great as war portrayals in Saka no Ue no Kumo in any other Japanese TVs in my opinion and it involved many international actors too that made the drama looks more believable.
Their research on the military equipment, navy fleets and gunneries (not only for the Japan but for other countries), as well as the communication during that time period, is something to be praised for. If you like war and military you wouldn't want to miss this one.
Thank you so much! I'm a novice of Japanese history but this period has really captured my interest. I've learned…
Thanks for reading my review, and for writing nice comment about it! I really appreciate it.
I'm not an expert in Japanese history and I only learn from drama and wiki...lol In other words, I have limited reference when it comes to this subject...So please don't take my opinion seriously other than as a casual J-historical drama fan.
To be honest I can't remember any Shiba clan involvement in this drama, maybe it was there but I have somehow missed it or I have forgotten about it. So, to answer your question I looked at the wiki page too
My wild guess is that, they used Ashikaga name until the establishment of Ashikaga Shogunate. They owned the "Shiba" name at the end of 13th century but they were probably stick with Ashikaga. Maybe they couldn't change the name without Kamakura (Hojo) permission. That's why after new Shogunate formed they were able to request to use the new name. Just my wild wild guess though...
It is also possible to change the name back and forth as what happened to Kiso Yoshinaka when he became the Shogun during late Heian after chasing Taira out of Kyoto. He revert back to Minamoto then. He was originally Minamoto. When he resided in Kiso, he changed to Kiso, but then changed back to Minamoto when he became Shogun.
But there were no "samurai ethics" yet during that time, so maybe this example can't be applied to Shiba's case.
Yes, this movie is good and fun... UNTIL IT MAKES IT'S MIND IN THE END THAT IT NEEDS TO END BAD!I HATE IT!Seriously,…
Haha...I totally agree with you! I don't like the ending either. I think the message was too shallow. I guess a more typical ending without the "love confession" would be good enough for this kind of movie.
This drama is good but it would've been excellent if they could put more effort on the actions part as well as the CGI. I also noticed TBS broadcast and Netflix have different cuts respectively (as the ripped sub won't sync so easily with the TV raw). I wonder if it makes any different.
Not bad. Very fun and entertaining movie. It was the typical work drama, but the kind that you will never get tired of and it could give inspiration to anyone who is just to enter work-life and fresh college graduates who are hating their jobs.
So, i'm here to whine. 1st episode in kinda ok, a bit dumb moment like why the hell the spotter didn't inform…
The one in Ep1 wasn't the criminal. He was the supposed "informer" to Ayano Go. The team went to save him (the informer) after the kidnapper close the curtain, remember? I imagine they (informer and kidnapper) got out of building during this time.
Suzu was there just for marketing. The drama actually feels like it was made for Ichikawa Ebizo's fan only. Quite boring the way they presented it to be honest, although they didn't skew much from the history.
He was probably killed by another Public Safety officer to conceal his identity as we have been given the clue…
Exactly...I wish for a clear closure too. In my opinion the deduction by Sara (on the Saito incident) was too speculative and he didn't have proof to back his claim. But the way Noma-san reacted at the end (by saying Sara passed the test) was left us for another speculation...haha
no but who the f killed Saito... how dare they not answer that question lol
He was probably killed by another Public Safety officer to conceal his identity as we have been given the clue that he carried automatic gun (instead of revolver that normally used by the crime detective) and the killer took it from the scene. It's just my wild guess though.
what did you think about this final ? -------------------------------------------------I liked this ending but…
The ending is a bit disappointing. I was hoping Sugano would be stabbed by the taxi driver not the other way round. After he did all those crimes he did not feel guilty at all. 15 years of jail was not a justified punishment for this kid.
Makoto isn't punished because he's cooperating with police IMO. They could have made some deal beforehand.
1 
1 
The action scene during the war was really jaw dropping. It's rare to see something as great as war portrayals in Saka no Ue no Kumo in any other Japanese TVs in my opinion and it involved many international actors too that made the drama looks more believable.
Their research on the military equipment, navy fleets and gunneries (not only for the Japan but for other countries), as well as the communication during that time period, is something to be praised for. If you like war and military you wouldn't want to miss this one.
I'm not an expert in Japanese history and I only learn from drama and wiki...lol In other words, I have limited reference when it comes to this subject...So please don't take my opinion seriously other than as a casual J-historical drama fan.
To be honest I can't remember any Shiba clan involvement in this drama, maybe it was there but I have somehow missed it or I have forgotten about it. So, to answer your question I looked at the wiki page too
My wild guess is that, they used Ashikaga name until the establishment of Ashikaga Shogunate. They owned the "Shiba" name at the end of 13th century but they were probably stick with Ashikaga. Maybe they couldn't change the name without Kamakura (Hojo) permission. That's why after new Shogunate formed they were able to request to use the new name. Just my wild wild guess though...
It is also possible to change the name back and forth as what happened to Kiso Yoshinaka when he became the Shogun during late Heian after chasing Taira out of Kyoto. He revert back to Minamoto then. He was originally Minamoto. When he resided in Kiso, he changed to Kiso, but then changed back to Minamoto when he became Shogun.
But there were no "samurai ethics" yet during that time, so maybe this example can't be applied to Shiba's case.
BTW, out of curiosity here's my quick googling on male centered definition
https://www.google.com/search?client=firefox-b-d&q=male+centered+meaning
Makoto isn't punished because he's cooperating with police IMO. They could have made some deal beforehand.