VrindaAV

oh did not notice or know the misquote of Carl Sagan.
Yes some small cameos when characters are established fully is fine . Here it is like put focus on these instead of some good character development of any of the main characters! At this point we hardly no background of Eve except that she is with someone and not that emotionally attached most likely and that she is here for some experiment. What about her family etc. May be next few episodes they will explore that but still it was better to focus on her .

Yes! padding is the word. Could be editing as well which means director is not clear what he wants leading to poor post prod editing

After watching two episodes I guess why most of us having mixed feelings is mainly because of the screenplay. Casts, direction, CGI, humour everything is good but what i felt lacking is screenplay. There are a lot of incoherences between scenes.
For ex: the scenes where all were celebrating after the successful surgery in the space there were same exact response by the characters that were repeated many times. Its like you turn and smile and the same action getting repeated again instead of continuing the scene after that.
I felt that even be it swimming pool scene though hilarious need not be that long . I laughed first then fast forwarded bcs it did not seem to end.
Then the random cartoonish lego type thing that came up showing all the 6 people's resting place i suppose. That popped up out of nowhere when Gong Ryong was giving icecreams and then it goes back to him still holding icecreams. instead if this was popped right before everyone goes to sleep or somethign made more sense to me. (I am open to correcton if this is just my problem)
All this leads to slight disinterest in the whole flow without us realising.
As to romantic part its not a typical KDrama romance which depends on people's taste i suppose.
Just my perspective. Still not a bad start for a drama i would say

😀 I always try to be respectful towards others opinion. At the end everyone has their own thoughts and perspectives. So we can agree to disagree. Even when you ,from the first comment outright started berating me I was still answering you respecting your thoughts but then. .. First of all you come to my review and give lecture how I dont understand anything and then also rant that I actually gave a review. I see in another review you were upset that the person did not explain why the show was bad and now that I have explained you have a problem that I did!!. anyways as someone in the other thread said since you are obsessed about lecturing everyone that this show is so good , there will be more negative reviews that will be coming. You can go and rant your so called non existent depth of the show there. Save your energy because there will be more coming. Okay this is actually my last response. There is no point in responding to a person who from the get go instead of trying to have a healthy discussion just lectures on how bad my understanding of world is. Anyways Peace! Enjoy the show with all its depth and whatever this show offers you.

I solely blame on the plot that lead to lack of feelings for the characters. So i am not backtracking anything. I did not even read fully your long message. This is the last response from me. Why bother with my review if you have so much problem with it. Just enjoy the show no? Why are you bothering to force what you feel on me. I will never agree in what you say and you will not agree to mine. We can simply agree to disagree. As simple as that.
I have the right to give my review and i gave my thoughts. If you dont know, the point of review is give out your thoughts for people who are interested to read and form their own opinion. We can give reviews for shows which we like and for shows we dont like. If the point of reviews was only to give for the shows we liked, all shows would be ranked 10! That is just a silly point to make. I watched a show , i reviewed it and i will move on . And my review for this show in short is
This is an ok enjoyable one time see drama not more than that . Thats it!
Please enjoy the show all you want . Peace!

I think you did not understand when i meant i did not feel anything when ML cried. It is because the plot made me lose interest so i did not care after a while.
At the end it is overall I found it an average drama which is enjoyable at one go but not a memorable one. There is no such "rigid" , "misguided" or any such terms whatsoever stopping me from enjoying it. I did not enjoy because it lacked clear consistent plot and had plot holes and a lot of typical cliche scenes.
Anyways this long response of yours just shows you are very emotionally attached to the show. You do you. Just Enjoy the show. I have expressed my thoughts in the platform where everyone can express their thoughts . No need to put so much analysis on my mere drama review and waste your precious time lol .

Got interested in K drama after long despite it having a lot of typical K Drama cliche scenes but it still works somehow. There are lot of unrealistic things as well. How come HuiJoo and BSK stayed in same house for 3 years and still the world did not come to know. BSK challenges media people to investigate on him. First thing anyone would do is keep someone near his home to see who enters and exits . He even need not challenge. Any media wanting some spicy scoop would have easily found out long back no?

Exactly my thoughts! You put all my thoughts into words.
First thing that really put me off is knowing that he already loved . How, why and when. Just because of her running in the rain smiling ?? Villian and the police department were ultimate jokes in the name of the plot .

Exactly the relationship is so surface level. Even the friendshop with 2nd ML. All of a sudden they are buddies travelling to a coastal place. Everything is out of nowhere!

whatever you say dearie there are people out there who did not like this show. chill and peace out :)

So true. i was so disappointed because this plot could have been handled with so much maturity and could be one of the best

well. there are lot of people who agree to this review but just dont bother adding the review.

Tell me about it ! And FL is supposed to be 34 year old (although in a body of 20 year old ) and they sometime act like kids let alone teenage years when she is supposed to be out of it !

100% agree. It had a potential to be as good as Someday or one day but sigh ...

100% on point. Its like clicking on all the cliche check boxes and it still works among youngsters bcs they are good looking people ! I am okay with cliches if the relationship is built on solid base but here nope

Oh finally someone sharing my thoughts. Him having crush ruined it for me.Like what! After that i went haywire. Its like random fluffy scenes but if that relationship doesnt develop i cant get invested however good looking actors are. Like really they havent shared one single good discussion so far. Like literally nothing on their life , career passion nothing.. . Like i wanted that relationship to develop but well... apart from some really absurd annoying out of nowhere sequences for ex: fire sequence . It did nothing to add to the plot. It just comes and goes.

Agree. I just started yesterday and its like writers have mood swings. Some parts are real good and some are so badly written. Plot itself is fine its more execution and details part of it i suppose which is bad in certain sequence (fire sequence is the worst if you ask me)

Double post was by mistake . One was supposed to be an independent feedback on the show. not to make my point. Yes we can agree to disagree i just gave my perspective

haha agree but this is how real life is !! And this comes very close to that. They act like normal people which is rare !

FL is very young who has first time stepped out of her village ( that too from a village where everyone ignored them) so when she meets a upright , helpful and sensitive official in such a big position like ML she is bound to act like she met pop artist idol lol. Why cant she admire the person who treated her so well and is the personification of the ideal "judge" whose stories she has been listening since she was a kid. I found their interaction normal not over the top. For once ML & FL are not pig headed but communicate like normal people. Admire each other for their talents openly and actually listen to each other.