Pincolino

Ji Woo said in his monologue at the end of Ep 8 how important Seo Joon was for him ... that he will be with him forever, because he had such an impact on his life.

Imagine you have someone who is so important to you, someone you admire and love - wouldn't you try to do your best to make him happy? Wouldn't you be inspired to become the best version of yourself? Nope. This really went in the wrong direction.

But do you really feel the love? At this point I think even their chemistry faded away. I see two complex characters who are drawn to each other, hurt each other. At this point it's just a mind game. I'm still confused about them apparantly sleeping together, when they can't even talk to each other properly. The physical and emotional aspect of that love story was completely neglected.

I think the author miscalculated. They thought we would root for Ji Woo to the end, because he is suffering so much. As if his suffering is an excuse for everything. They just went too far.

Tharntype is the definition of trash, similar to KinnPorsche. Both remind me of my young days when I read trashy fanfictions from people who don't know anything about storytelling, about characters and about life, but are successful because their stories are "edgy" as much as unrealistic and not relatable. How that child abuse trauma was handled in TharnType ...! No words. The VegasPete story in KinnPorsche ...! That's something for the brain dead. But we all know 50 shades of grey got a bestseller, so that's the quality the main stream enjoys. Same trash.

But I must admit when watching To My Star I feel similar. It's the other side of the coin: Poeple who lose themselves in depressive/angsty content while writing because they try to hard to make it "realistic". The author went deep down that depression hole. As a writer you have to please your audience and tell an engaging story. There was no character development shown until now. At episode 8 (!!) we saw Ji Woo finally sad and Seo Joon given somehow up, though I still fear he will take him back in a heart beat if Ji Woo runs crying to him. We understood his depression after two episodes. There was no need to drag this out and make the character so unlikable, that viewers don't even root for him. Depression is not easy to overcome, but again, a writer has to entertain the audience and evoke different feelings. This is the same stuff over and over again to the bitter end. Though I guess, it won't be that bitter. I still think we will get a Happy End.

Honestly, I'm not happy how they developed the Ji Woo character, and I think they overdid it with the angst. The mood throughout the whole series is too depressing. But overall this isn't bad. I enjoy it a lot, and will watch it to the end for sure. It was worth my time. Also talking about it is a lot of fun. If they give us a happy end, I'm here for it. And if it's not done well or plausible, I can't wait to complain about it, lol.

Didn't even watch Ep 3, but that made me laugh so much!

I don't think so. Ji Woo was holding back his tears. I rewatched that scene, because I didn't notice the first time. He KNEW what he was doing. And Seo Joon knew he would do it! He was fearful Ji Woo would say harsh things again. You could see how nervous he was. He openly admitted it, that he thought Ji Woo would tell him it was a mistake, but what he said then was even worse. That scene was honestly one of the worst of the whole series. Very hard to watch.

It's complex, but I will break it down to this:
Seo Joon never hurt Ji Woo INTENTIONALLY. Ji Woo on the other hand lied and said harsh things knowing very well it will hurt Seo Joon. He just took it too far, especially after they kissed and apparantly slept together. That's the issue I have with the character. It indeed makes him a questionable person. He should have found a better way to deal with Seo Joon. I comdemn his behaviour from a moral point of view. I myself could never hurt someone who is dear to me so much just because I'm insecure and can't handle my emotions.

Him being hurt is not an excuse for his behaviour. He brought that mess upon himself, and he dragged down Seo Joon with him.

It's getting worse.

Yeah, I know, but they were both drunk. Don't want to defend Vee, he was such an a**hole in the first series. I just feel it's slightly better in the remake. The plot is messy. I watch this for the good filmmaking and the chemistry, not for the plot. Not a fan of it.

I thought we would see that after Ep 6 when Seo Joon heard the conversation with the ex and got into his van. But no.

If two people are involved who have romantic feelings for each other, it's always a love story, I guess. And we all know you have to love yourself first, before you can love someone else.

I don't think Seo Joon can help Ji Woo overcome his problems. He has to do it himself. For me this is more a journey of a guy who finally has to break out of the prison he created for himself.

I don't think that those who don't like it don't understand it.

The issue is more that for some people Ji Woo's inner turmoil is not a good enough explanation for his cruel behaviour. I know what kind of story the author was trying to tell. But there could have been a better plot. They could have provided us with a more engaging story. At this point this is not even a love story. It's about Ji Woo unsuccessfully fighting his own demons.

Ji Woo has to get out of his depressive shell. He has to overcome his gloomy self. How?

But I also hope Seo Joon will reject him. That would change the dynamic, so Ji Woo must chase after him and showing some will power. Until now he only run away.

Well, he didn't know it WITH him either

I don't think he sees it as "cheating". In the first series it was even worse. He was openly chasing after Mark while at the same time maintening a relationship with Ploy.

In this version it seems he isn't really aware at this point that he is interested in Mark. He behaved like he wanted to know him better (like he wanted to date him which I know is also strange), but he wasn't so straight-forward to tell him he wants to have sex again.

After Ep 3 I guess the cheating will now start. They will sleep with each ohter while at the same time Vee is unable to break up with Ploy.

I think the biggest problem of the whole season is how they managed to make Ji Woo such an unlikable character. In s1 he was awkward, cold, said harsh things, but he was also cute, adorable and occasionally looked really happy. He smiled several times, he was the better basket ball player, he seemed curious about Seo Joon and the world around him. He liked to tease him. He was also stubborn and had his pride. There is a lot to say about that character. He was very complex. I really liked him back then. Not to mention that he came across as a genuine and good guy.

In s2 though ... what to say? Horrible person with no good qualities left. Didn't even smile once. All the dialogues he had until now were depressing, doesn't matter who he talks with. Looking at him makes me feel miserable.

That kiss was perfectly acted, and how Mark pressed his lips before going for it ... perfect ...

I don't think they want us to understand, lol.
I too thought there was more about it. But I doubt at this point that we will get to see a big plot twist in the last two epidoses.