Kate

The production was amazing but the story was so meh. Especially since they did not end up being siblings... what even. Without it this drama isn't exactly anything special in terms of plot....

I loved this drama but I really disliked the ending. I get that they are hinting 2nd season and it make sense to leave some plot points open to come back to them in next season, but there was no closure at all in it...

Thanks for the into :) Tbh culture has a huge impact on how people act in general. In most places I was visiting people do stare a lot when someone looks different but mosty if it's by their choice (for example they dress 'funny' or have 'funny' hair). Usually with a physical disability (mental one is a whole different story) people just ignore it...

the scene when he is on a wheelchair and EVERYONE looks at him weirdly and comments and shit. This does not happen in real life never. Sure there will always be some assholes who react in a weird way but the truth is, majority of people just does not care. They could have made this scene amazing. Show it in two perspectives: filmed from behind Soo Yeon and we see people talking about him and commenting and being 'concern' and then wide shot and no one really caring. It would show how insecure he is about his disability in a more interesting way.

I don't care what is canon and what other people say, I see the romance between Hwa Pyung and Yoon. There was a huge difference in dynamics and chemistry between the dudes and Kil Yeong and them with each other. Even she brought up that they should get along with each other and how Hwa Pyung has Yoon so why is he calling her. Those were just a small moments but put together give a bigger picture of their relationship and feelings. The whole scene at the end underwater was amazing. They were both ready to die for each other. Not to mention ocn ships them too, seeing how they uploaded a short mv dedicated to their 'bromance'.
Anyway, the drama is 10-/10. The - is given just because I was hoping for some hugs between the trio at the end...
ALSO I WILL KILL FOR 2ND SEASON.

Well now I am screwed, coz YouTube Premium is not available in Poland... I saw the 1st 3 eps and now I can't watch the rest... what is life? I already love this drama...

I HATE THIS ENDING on a whole new level of hate. Love the drama tho. but last ep... tragic..

I was like that too... and since I had the theory about where it's going I ask someone who seen the jap. ver to tell me if I am right and (sadly) I was. I needed to know coz it was one of my plot pet peeves . Now that I know it I just spoil ,myself with everything and open all spoiler comments. BUT if you know nothing about the future episodes and have no predication you would want to confirmed I'd say stay away from hidden comments coz majority of them have spoilers in.

For now I think they are going with him knowing she is his sister (the way he reacts to her talking about her brother and her growing up with some hardships, but she might not know and fall for him. They won't go anywhere romantically speaking (since he knows) but emotionally it will still be tragic coz she will be hurt in the process since she is being kept in the dark.

I'm late for the party but omg they translated spieprzaj as 비켜! 비켜, 빨리! WATCH ME DYING OVER IT HAHAHAHA shout-out to all polish fans hahaha

I just hate how they made is quite obvious they are siblings but Moo Young keeps saying shit like '나랑 사귀자' and 'our date seems too short'... it's a bit reaching and honestly makes me uncomfortable. I'm pretty chill about majority of taboo topics but incest is something I just can't handle...

and now I might drop the drama tbh. Coz if it was just this huge plot twist I might love it (if I didn't know about it) but since now I know I will just feel REALLY awkward watching it. The writing is so vague about whenever the chemistry between Moo Young and Jin Kang is romantic or siblings one it might be much to handle...

Everyone talks about this huge plot twist from jap. ver at the end. Please just tell me it's not Jin Kang and Moo Young being siblings or some shit like that and that Jin Gook killed their father and out of guilt took Moo Young as his sister and Jin Kang ended up in orphanage. Just someone who saw jap. ver tell me it's not true and don't give any other spoilers so I can watch it with peace lol

I like Ahn Hyo Seop but I was not too excited about him getting a lead role (since his acting is not exactly always the best. he was amazing in 30 but 17, but not too good in My Father is Strange). And if he lacks in acting in any area it would be obvious next to Yoo Jung who is literally an acting veteran at this point. so for me Gyun Sang is a safer choice.

For My ID is Gangnam Beauty casting older actress than the age of her character had a point plot wise if you read webtoon (in drama it was not so clear, maybe they deleted some scenes). Mirae was always being describes as looking older and more mature (partially coz of her surgeries and her body type) than Soo Ah. It was suppose to be like one of them looking like a woman and the other like an innocent girl.

That's probably true but it should be written as sci-fi then lol Coz it's medically unrealistic. Also him stopping car like that is unreal even with some high tech bionic arm, since to stop it you would have to use other muscles in your body that are not as strong as his arm... I think they might have overdo it... Also he did bleed from the arm so he can't be amputee... For now there ins't any reasonable explanation to what is going on hahaha

I mean, sure lying is definitely going on. He is getting better so we CANNOT talk about any atrophy going on. But honestly his WHOLE amnesia doesn't make sense. He should be waking up everyday thinking it's the day right after the accident (or the day he woke up from the accident). Just reading from his journals what happened day before would not be enough for him to live a life he is living right now lol

true but there is also no fantasy nor sci-fi attached to it hahaha while in a robot romance we had sci-fi hahaha They could have just not speak of any atrophy of the brain in last ep and I would not have any problem, but since they brought it, they need to explain. The miracles are usually the type of 'the surgery that has at most 5% chances of success' and not curing someone of literally incurable disease. They are really reaching with this one hahaha
But yeah, it's kdrama, I don't really watch it for it's logic.

I am not sure it's dementia tho. majority of dementia types are really slow process with no major jumps in symptoms. He was getting better (remembering some stuff from the past and meetings with Gi Beum) but now in 7th ep he after the headache does not remember even things from the same day. I guess it might be vascular dementia since his symptoms are all over the place, and that's the only one fitting his criteria but still it's kind of weird. It might be caused coz of injury (aka his car accident) but the weird pattern of his symptoms progressing... I am not sure it makes much sense.

If it's really atrophy of neurons in his brain then it's kind of done deal and he won't get better. At most they may slow down or stop the process, but with them claiming it's atrophy he should not be able to regain 'what he already lost'. I'm not even sure if progressing atrophy can occur with someone who just had an accident unless they were not treated properly , but even then I am not sure this is truly possible. The car accident is a one time event that may damage your brain and IF there is a swelling or cerebral haemorrhage I guess the consequences can be longer term... but with him being so young and overall healthy I am not sure if he could be still getting worse if he was treated properly in the 1st place... that said I study neuropsychology and I'm not a medical student so I might be wrong, since my medical knowledge is limited. Unless they give us some good explanation later on, I am not sure this drama can have happy ending.