Kate

I'd tried to find ost, but I'm pretty sure it's not out yet.

Even tho I said it myself after 1st ep that the probation guys would be a better suspect and criminal than Hyung Tae,now that he really is I'm kind of disappointed that.. it's kind of obvious too. If I was able to figure it out in 1st ep, then it was way too easy and in your face in the 1st place.
But still I think overall the drama is good, as long as you don;t think of it as kr Criminal Minds. Coz it's literally nothing alike.

I'm sorry but the 1st case (from the past) does not make any sense. They framed him for dementia right? So the interview could not be used as an evidence, but the bank statements are still valid evidence that is indisputable. I only saw first and second ep, so I don't know if they will explain it later, but for now I'll call it bullshit.

I like it, enjoy it for sure. There are some things that annoy me tho: except from Min Young and Lee Han other characters either don't make much sense or have close to zero personality, Na Hwang also is out there with the bubbly personality but it kind of feels... fake?
I also don't like the how the show the victims visually on those 'profile cards'... looks like from a cheep video game?
Overall it's kind of good. I hope the Hyung Tae is not really the accomplice. I think it's too easy. The detention center guy would make much more sense.

until the idea is scientifically proven to work, it's just an idea. Scientists test millions of different hypotheses because 'they might be right' but they more often tend to not work out. the name 'speculative fiction' is really good, but as I said it is still fiction. I love how they tackled with more realistic ideas in this drama and they did not go full fantasy land (tho some ideas were dumb, like who would EVER want transparent phone? I would lose it and never find it again hahaha) but still none of the technology they have (in that state, aka yep cloning is possible to some extend, cloning human being and for them to actually be healthy and survive the proces: nope) exist. We don't even know for sure with 100% certainty how memory work, there are quite a few theories and all of them sound logical. so we are far from creating anything even close to what they had i drama.
This conversation is way too serious tho hahaha I'm just too skeptical. But I LOVE sci-fi too. IT's my 2nd fav genre (right after horror hahaha).

I clearly stated 'in our times' coz it is impossible IN OUR TIMES. Don't know if you read my comment till the end. It's still fiction even if it's based on science. Possibilities are still just that, they are not facts. Possibilities are never ending. Until those technologies exist in real life, it is fiction. Estimations of what will and will not be possible in the future are far from accurate since there is way too many variables to take into account. Based on what sci-fi movies presented right now we should have flying boards and cars, robots walking around and working with us on daily basis. There is a reason why we have 'fiction' in science-fiction genre. Because it's fiction, that may or may not happen in a far future.

I mean they said few times during drama that the knowledge Byul gave them was much more than just the one they used for memories. They even tried to pass the bill for cloning (probably for harvesting them for organs or just extending human life by making new body and uploading the memories in when the person is close to dying. I don't think drama needs to explain EVERYTHING in detail. It would take too long and would be simply boring and the majority of the audience would not understand the science talk. I like the idea that Byul just shared all the knowledge she had as an alien but then they tried to use it 'in a bad way'....

well that's why it's under sci-fi... coz it;s impossible in real life. And they said many times during drama that the knowledge and technology Byul gave can be used for much more than playing with other people memories. The 1st thing she 'did' was 'download' Woojin's memories as a video. If you can download it I see no reason why it would be impossible to upload it. In the drama they treated memories as a data and the brain as a computer. And you can move data from computer to computer. That one was easily explained.
They didn't really explain why and how did Woojin wake up, but they did explain how the supercomputer closed. Woojin needs to be in the same room as supercomputer, so when he got out of the room the whole system shut down.
I mean no movie or drama under sci-fi will be 'logical' in our times coz it's fiction after all. It's fiction based on science.

BUT for Woojin's clone he is Woojin. There is nothing that separates him from Woojin. He is not his own person, he is another Woojin. They have the same memories, the same feelings and same characteristics. There is nothing unique and individual about the clone. There is not easy way out of this situation. If you treat him as Woojin it wouldn't be fair for the real one. If you don't treat him as Woojin it wold be not fair for the clone, because as far as he know HE IS Woojin. I mean... technically he is. Because what makes a person? If it's not the physical aspect (body and dna) and it's not the personality and memories then what is? I do think they should have shown all 3 of them visiting the grave but I see no problem with them treating Woojin as Woojin. If it's picking between being fair to a dead person and being fair and empathetic to living one, I'd chose the 2nd option.

I was soooo freaking happy they actually talked about why Kim Joon Hyuk does not wear glasses hahaha that's a small detail but it would bug me forever if they did not explain it.

@Moza omg I could not finish Tomorrow with You because of the romance. I found So Joon way too confusing. I also did not like the idea that at the beginning he basically used her to 'save himself'. I know A LOT of people loves that drama, but for me it was a little bit too messy like they tried too hard? I've seen 6 eps and I could not get into it.

I didn't mention FFMW in my comment. They do. They have really good chemistry. But lately there are more and more main couples that do not have chemistry and usually it's because they try to make them fall in love in first 3 eps in stead of giving us time to warm up to the couple. Or the plot is so ridiculous the idea of the main couple having feelings for each other just makes me angry (like with Whisper).

I feel like lately it is so hard to find new drama with a good chemistry between main characters. When I watch any interaction between Crown Prince and Ga Eun... I feel nothing. I have the same problem with Suspicious Partner...
There is also too many characters in this one, so I at the end I'm not emotionally invested in any, except from Woo Bo, whose story is honestly the most interesting.

are you a mother? coz if you are not then you don't know what you'd do in a situation like that. There is so many cases of parents killing people who hurt/killed their children. It's really not weird nor stupid. Being police officer she literally knew there is nothing she can do to get this kid for killing her child. If they did not prosecute the boy is the 1st place it's almost impossible for it to happen later on.

Well everyone was focusing on the person who tried to kill him and taking him out of that room, it's not weird they did not notice shit about his expression hahaha
And she might be a cop, but she is also a mother. Her child got killed and the law system she trusted failed. I do not think her reaction was stupid. It was a normal human reaction for this type of situation.

I am curious how they are going to explain Kim Joon Hyuk being related to Kim twins as their brother... Like... from the 1st part there was no indication they have any other brothers than each other. Now the question is: 형제 is a singular or plural noun? Coz if it can be used as singular Kim Joon Hyuk might be Kim Woo Jin in the future (it would fit with the age difference). This way the 'find your siblings' would mean 'find your sibling' <- singular aka Kim Bum Gyu. They also showed that he has some memories of the time twins spent together so it would kind of make sense if he was Kim Woo Jin?

Well he did covered the case so it would not even go to court. It's like they put him and keep in the prosecutor position to have an insider and later on (when he gains more power) he will be able to help the vigilantes from the inside. But to do that, he first needs to get his hand dirty here and there. That's what I meant when I say he is more in the gray area. Coz the end result is suppose to be good, but to get there he will have to do some questionable things.

I would not say he is a bad guy, but he is not a truly good guy either tbh. He is more on the gray area. I never understood when good characters did some bad/questionable things and when all 'for the greater good'. That's the same excuse many villains use too.

Well, they know he was on the roof. He did not deny going there with her, he denied pushing her off. That's how they framed it. So there is no problem with this. Truth to be told even if they did prosecute him and went to court, they would lost. There is no way of proving he killed her and since he doesn't even have a motive... it was a lost cause. Sadly.

It's not like they are trying to hide it. They showed him being the guy on the roof talking to the murderer on the phone. It suppose to be obvious. I don't think they were playing to use it as a plot twist or anything like that.