This review may contain spoilers
A Film That Changes Its Thesis in the Final Act
The first two acts of this film establish a clear and compelling thematic direction, only for the final act to quietly replace it.The opening is exceptional. It builds two ordinary people connecting without status hierarchy, romantic pedestal, or aspirational fantasy. Their relationship feels grounded, emotionally honest, and free from exaggerated melodrama. The thesis appears simple yet rare: that two common individuals can connect purely because they do.
The pacing is not slow—it is restrained. Each scene advances the psychological conflict with intention. The emotional progression leads naturally to the public confession, which functions as the true climax of the story. By that point, the arc feels complete. The transformation is earned through vulnerability, not spectacle.
The issue arises in the third act.
The sudden death of the male lead does not emerge from prior conflict, thematic groundwork, or character decisions. It functions primarily as an external shock. More significantly, the narrative reframes this tragedy as the catalyst for her empowerment.
From a structural and psychological standpoint, this shift feels unearned. A character defined by insecurity, avoidance, and a retreat into emotional darkness would not realistically find immediate strength in the loss of her only source of validation. The film replaces process with symbolism.
The original thesis suggested that connection itself was enough. The final act implies that loss is what grants that connection transcendence.
That shift alters the film’s identity.
Tragedy does not automatically deepen a story. Structural coherence does. And here, the coherence established so carefully in the first two acts gives way to impact-driven symbolism.
The foundation was strong. The final turn changes what the film ultimately stands for.
Was this review helpful to you?
8.2~⭐⭐⭐⭐
Secret: Untold Melody is a quiet, emotional mystery that slowly unfolds like a song you don’t fully understand at first but feel anyway.D.O. once again proves he’s a strong emotional lead. His performance is restrained and subtle, never overdramatic, yet deeply convincing. He carries the film with silence, with eyes that speak more than dialogue ever could.
The structure can feel slightly confusing in the beginning. The mystery builds in fragments, and at times it feels predictable. But just when you think you have it figured out, the story gently twists. It doesn’t shock loudly it clicks into place. Slowly. Carefully.
There’s a familiar emotional echo here, reminiscent of Ditto: that same nostalgic longing, that sense of love crossing something intangible. But this film plays its own melody. Softer. More restrained.
It’s not perfect, but it lingers. And sometimes, that’s enough.
Was this review helpful to you?
I can't get it out of my head.
Although I really enjoyed this movie, I wasn't going to write about it, because I thought I didn't have anything interesting to say, but almost a full 24 hours after watching it, I keep replaying it in my head, the more I think about it, the more I like it, the more the pain lingers so I have to put my thoughts about it in writing whether they're interesting or not.To My Beloved Thief changed my mind about Moon Sangmin, to me he was Just tall handsome guy who just stood there with the same confused expression no matter the situation his carachter is put in, the swimmer in Mermaid prince,the prince in under the Queen's Umbrella, younger guy dating older lady in Cinderella at 2 AM, all the same boring handsome dude ( he was good in Duty after school though, just as or maybe more disgusting than Taeman was in he webtoon). All that to say that I was looking foward to what he would do in Pavane and although he does have that confused handsome guy face in this one, it works so perfectly, Gyeongrok is a sad kid who has had a really tough life, the unflattering way dresses and that gloomy air around him, Moon Sangmin made me care for this guy so badly.
I love that Kim Mijeong kept her look throughout the movie, yes she was quirky, mousy and bashful, that eventually did get better, but finically, no makeup, simple clothing and hairstyle it was just her and she didn't need to change that. The way GyeongRok would light up when he saw her was like stepping into a whole new world, these two usually gloomy people would brighten up, smile, sing and dance, and make us root for their love.
Although the movie is a bit slow at times, it makes sense given the personalities of our two main leads, its a slow burn romance with a devastating ending but it is very much worth watching at least once.
Was this review helpful to you?
disapointing
acting and cast is not the same because we have a pretty cast with bad acting and a weird script, the start the plot is good but im confused by the direction it took. very cliche and almost a filler. with a movie every word should be important, but this feels like fluff. also the cinamtogrephy wasnt very impressive considering the tech japan has. they should have done better. howveer beautfiul fl and ml.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A magnificent movie, beautiful and moving
PLOT: Kosuke, a gay man (ostracized as a child and deeply affected by his mother's death), has built a tough armor in the Tokyo fashion scene. He meets Ryuta, a young man who works as a personal trainer to help him stay in shape. They fall in love. However, he discovers that Ryuta is working multiple jobs to support his mother, even resorting to prostitution. He helps Ryuta leave prostitution, meets Ryuta's mother, but Ryuta is working himself to death [literally]. Kosuke continues to care for Ryuta's mother.+++ The three actors, Suzuki Ryohei (Kosuke), Miyazawa Hio (Ryuta), and Agawa Sawako (his mother), are fantastic.
+++ The direction is intelligent and very contemporary. The story is realistic (life for gay people in Japan isn't easy; thankfully, there's support from the community).
### I don't particularly like the camerawork; it makes me uncomfortable at times.
I don't know what the film's message is, but it deals with love, family, and grief, and is overflowing with sensitivity and humanity.
************************************************
Magnifique film, beau et dur
PLOT: Kosuke, homme gay (ostracisé enfant et ayant bcp souffert de la mort de sa mère) s'est forgé une carapace dans les milieux de la mode à Tokyo. Il rencontre un jeune homme, Ryuta, coach, pr prendre soin de sa forme. Ils tombent amoureux. Cpdt, il découvre que Ryuta fait plein de boulots pr subvenir aux besoins de sa mère, mm se prostitue. Il lui fait quitter la prostitution, rencontre la mère de Ryuta, mais Ryuta se tue à la tâche [littéralement]. Kosuke va continuer à s'occuper de la mère de Ryuta.
+++ Les 3 acteurs, Suzuki Ryohei (Kosuke), Miyazawa Hio (Ryuta) et Agawa Sawako (sa mère) sont fantastiques.
+++ La réalisation est intelligente, très actuelle. La story est réaliste (la vie des gays au Japon n'est pas facile, heureusement qu'il y a le soutien de la communauté).
### Je n'aime pas bcp le travail de la caméra, qui me met mal à l'aise par moments.
=> Je ne sais pas quel est le message de ce film, mais il parle d'amour, de famille, du deuil et déborde de sensibilité et d'humanité.
Was this review helpful to you?
beautiful
deep and moving. i highly recomend, the communist sister is the best. i feel like rhey could habe done more detail but in 2 hours its hard. esoicallhh such an important story. i also feel so bad for the dad even if i like communist sister and i understand her. if i was the father i would defenitley kill her husband. even though i was sad when the husband died. i dont think any parent would allow it. thank god i dont have kids i would freak..Was this review helpful to you?
More a comedy with some sincere moments than a romance
This quirky rom-com (featuring an aspiring pâtissier possessed by a demon and a jobless guy) is much more focus on the comedy aspect than on the romance which is never very deepened.However, I did not mind at all that is was not really a romance. On the contrary, I liked that the writing put the focus on the demon / human relationship. The ending opened the doors to more and even if it felt a bit abrupt, overall it was a nice watch.
Yoona really did an excellent job showcasing diametrically different personalities while giving the male lead (played by Ahn Bo Hyun) full whiplash effect.
I would recommend this to people looking for a comedy with some heartfelt moments. The romance is really not the main aspect of the story but I think it is worth a shot as I found the storytelling around the fantasy elements super interesting with some very well made background regarding the curse.
Was this review helpful to you?
Inspired me to live my life,not others
wtf I just finished it and my shirt is drenched with tears,this movie pulls at the heartstrings alright. I advise u to have tissues near by😭This is absolutely gonna be one of the movies i'll rewatch over and over again,and never get tired of. Some many moving and relateble themes and scenes.Truely a true comfort movie."Instead of keeping up with the pace of the world, I think it's better to live at your own pace"- Mi Jeong
Was this review helpful to you?
so insightful.
movies like this make me remember why i cant stomach romance harem dramas like swords and the brocade. This is real and not a game which you can win. but something which always had trapped and imprisoned real women. no women can win this, its so cunning the system it tries to condition you and this movie shows that so well. the little foot massages and even the character progression. chills down my spine. concubine harem dramas should take some inspo and not make it the true evil insesntive all fightimg for one man with no dimmension. just villians but motive and a misundersrood ml. but 35 and 15 is never romance. instead its this a girl who goes mad, not a girll who wins and beats the system.Was this review helpful to you?
Action Pack Movie
I just finished watching The Shadow's Edge. This movie is intense and thrilling. The cast did an outstanding job. the fight scenes were amazing and the ost is awesome. Bravo 👏👏👏The fight scenes of Jackie and Tony was great.
I was startled so many times that jump out of my seat.
Awesome movie highly recommended 👌
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
WHAT THE FUCK DID I SUBJECT MY EYES TO??!!
First off, to call this movie crazy is an understatement. This movie is bat-shit, cuckoo for puff puff, crack head wrapped in a world of blood and gore insane.When I saw the cover of the movie, I thought it would be your run-of-the-mill bully gets comeuppance movie. HOW WRONG WAS I.
Everyone in the movie except perhaps the parents, grandad and the kid sis of Haruka, everyone else in the small town has lost their goddamned braincells.
Almost all of the parents in the village are consumed with themselves and their expectations of their teenage children. Those that show a bit of concern are massive enablers. Do whatever you want parents.
And don't get me started on the teacher. I know a teacher's job is a herculean one - I know cos I'm one myself - but this teacher is totally useless. Though she was bullied when she was a student herself, she should have used her past to become better and stopped the bullies but she just kept quiet and just puked her guts out in almost all her scenes. She's just as bad as her students or even worst than they are.
Then the students or do I call them Teenagers from Hell. You can't even root for anyone. At one point, I was wishing Haruka would just lose control of her psychotic state and just set the whole village on fire 🔥🔥.
Anyway, the movie is quite good but don't go in expecting a rom-com.
Was this review helpful to you?
It's Hard to Condense 1,350 Minutes down to 103
I can't be objective, because I watched the drama, and it fleshed out the story in a way the movie can't. This is the Cliff Notes version. Without Yang Yang.Angelababy is anime pretty. I hadn't watched anything with her before, although many of the supporting actors were familiar (waves to Tan Song Yun and Li Xian).
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Beautiful and slow-paced movie
Everything about this movie is so beautiful, pure and heartbreakingly real. It's perfect if you want something to watch while overstimulated or just ready to get a bit sad lol. So content with it!The storyline was very deep and while some parts were confusing I overall enjoyed it a lot, especially that they didn't create the perfect happy ending you're used to get. It was nice to see Yo Han getting better at the end though!
(I'm proud because I actually predicted that Gyeong Rok would die.)
Was this review helpful to you?
It shows a lot of different ways love occurs, in an everyday way
I couldn't love an actor more than Huang Chin Chi. Both he and the actor who playesd his little brother in this short film were very good. It was a well written story, but the real delight was that the acting was entirely facial and physical. You could have deleted the dialog and soundtrack and still had quite the same experience, that is how good they were.People will tend to complicate the reviews here. If you love stories about love, if you have ever loved a sibling, if a parent has ever loved you distantly and unconventionallly, if you've ever had to take a minute, this 16ish minutes will light up your soul.
I rated highly because it made me remember when love was simple, and the only answer, before life got difficult and confusing.
I hope to see Huang Chun Chi in more prominent and starring roles in the future. His skills are excellent.
Was this review helpful to you?
FILM YANG GW PIKIR AKAN BOSENIN. TERNYATA... SEINDAH INI ?
Awal tau film ini dari trailer IG Netflix, dan disitu gw ada komen kalau sinematografinya vibe Jepang gitu. Gw suka betapa naturalnya mereka, no make up no filter.Film ini udah masuk watchlist, cuma emang ga ngeh kalau rilisnya today.
Daaaan sehabis pulang kerja, sampai rumah. Gw liat notif FILM INI SUDAH RILIS! Auto nonton, 3 detik pertama gw sempet mikir "ah kok" karena abis liat siapa yg muncul diprolog. Eh ga perlu nunggu lama 3 menit pertama film ini bikin gw lanjut nonton, dan selesai gitu aja pas gw rebahan, ga ada gw pause, ga ada gw skip, ga ada kedistract. Beneran MENIKMATI banget filmnya. Gw suka gimana cut to cut film ini! Cepet! Tipe movie yg gw sukak.
Agak jarang ya, Film Korea genre romance, drama, melodrama ini POV nya lebih ke si cowok. Atau sebenernya banyak, mungkin ga ketonton sama gw, karena yg gw ngeh mostly POV cewe.
Gw suka gmn obrolan ML dan FL difilm ini. Sebenarnya ini film yg bisa ketebak gmn alurnya, TAPI TETEP AJA GW GA NYANGKA KALO ITU BENERAN SESUAI APA TEBAKAN GUA. But it's okeee. Gua terima pake nangiiiis kejer nontonnya. Mau gimana emdingnya, gw suka gimana "berprosesnya" perasaan mereka satu sama lain, gmn hubungan manusia di film ini, walaupun ga detail dan basa-basi, tapi tersampaikan aja.
Film ini bukan cerita romance ala CEO tampan kaya ketemu cewe miskin lalu jatuh cinta. POKOKNYA KALIAN WAJIB NONTON!
Was this review helpful to you?
