News
Palace Intrigue with Ghosts and Monsters
#Halloween WatchesThe East Palace was drenched with the blood of maidservants, princes, concubines, and anyone else foolish enough to capture attention. Gu Cheon was brought into the palace, very much against his will, to exorcise the spirits who caused such death and despair.
The Good:
• Nam Joo Hyuk has returned from his military service with a more mature edge. I'm glad to see him evolve from parts as a college student into an action hero role. He played Gu Cheon perfectly: a man who'd been traumatized and ostracized and whose daily existence was one of bare survival. He wasn't the classical charming hero: he was sullen, hostile, and standoffish with his unkempt clothing and uncombed hair. All the poor man wanted was to be left alone, but neither the supernatural nor the humans would let him be.
• Roh Yoon Seo played Princess Saeng Gang with strength and intelligence. She'd suffered trauma and could empathize with Gu Cheon, even when he was being sarcastic and difficult. Her interactions with Gu Cheon, though they were terse and combative, were more interesting than most romance couples.
• There were some visually magnificent scenes.
• The music enhanced the action.
• The drama was dark and deadly with twists and revelations. I appreciate a story that can keep me guessing.
The Bad:
• Some CGI monsters were more comical looking than scary. One was supposed to be cute, and it was in that I'll-eat-your-face-off kind of way. The little ggeomeoksali provided the only light moments in the drama. I know it's a monster, but I'd probably end up taking it home with me.
So far, The East Palace was the spookiest of my October watches. It was drenched in supernatural atmosphere, kept the tension ratcheted, and told a compelling story (which only proved to strengthen my opinion that 99.9% of all palaces in K- and C-dramas should be nuked from space). I'm not admitting to being a wimpy scaredy-cat, but if I could handle this, Gentle Viewer, I think most people could.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Damned if you do, damned if you don't
“If I could spend eternity with you, eternity would feel like the blink of an eye. But even if it were only the blink of an eye, I would cherish every moment for as long as I could.” Ken in his poet era, here we go again.HOLY FUCKING SHIT. Nour, the show you are. All in all, I lowkey loved this show. From the start to the end, I was so fucking invested; we did OUR BIG ONE WITH THIS. Okay, so I would give it a 9.15 out of 10. Then I am going to say what I liked, what I didn't, and then do an episode overview and lay this great show to rest. (Also, disclaimer: no matter what I say, good or bad, you should watch this show lmao).
Starting off strong with what I liked: THE ACTING AND THE CHEMISTRY. Just all around, really good for everyone in this, even the characters that got killed off and were not in our 3 couples; phenomenal job, and this was very impressive. Good job, especially to our main couple. I have never seen Boss before because this is his first gig, but I love me some Tongtong, and these two together really brought the story to life in a way I would have never suspected, so just good job, and this is truly one of the strongest points in the show.
Next up for things I liked, I would have to say the plot. I was truly invested from start to the end, and I think that is because they did the plot well. My main criticism of shows that follow the supernatural and police investigator theme is that they have to pick either a good plot or a good romance, but I think that this show almost balanced it perfectly, and I love that. I was really worried that it would end just like all the others, but it didn't, and I was truly impressed. The directing, the screenwriting- really, everything was done very well, and it became a nice full-circle moment at the end.
Another thing that I really liked was Ken's character. Ken is our main character, and the show starts off with him and, of course, his mission to find the Nour who can kill Nours so he can finally die. He killed himself 253 times and is now working on a case to find that Nour, and I just love that so much. He is very emotionless but has this almost sad look on his face, which is due to Tongtong's beautiful but very sad face, and just yes. He doesn't know how to use electronics because he never learned. Everything in his house is old; he has a signed album from Elvis, stained glass in his house, old expired ramen- just everything was fucking perfect. I feel like they really didn't need these details, but it added to everything and just made Ken's character truly one of the best in the show (ALSO SPECIAL MENTION TO THE RANT ABOUT HOW NOTHING IN HIS LIFE HAS EVER BELONGED TO HIM BECAUSE HE ALWAYS HAS TO TAKE PEOPLE'S IDENTITIES AND IN TURN HE IS LOSING HIMSELF, GOOD FUCKING NIGHT).
Chita. HOLY FUCKING SHIT. If I didn't get spoilers from the literal actors' Instagram, I would have been so gagged, but fuck. He has such an unassuming face, so I think that the reveal was even worse, my god. Just a really well-written character with a tragic (rightfully) end to his story. I like the slow reveal of his whole character. I do think that they needed a better justification for ALL OF THE FUCKING KILLING HE WAS DOING. But I also understand his hate for other Nours because he was killed by one, brought back to life, and then left to die in a fucking house fire by the one who was supposed to love him, like come on now, I would be mad too. But yeah, loved his character, and I hope for like a couple more happy clips of him and Jira, because I don't know if I can handle the way their story ended.
THE SEX SCENE (for our main MAIN couple). I think in recent years of watching Thai dramas, I of course try to be more and more woke and not only watch Thai dramas for sex, but this was so beautifully done I can't help but talk about it. I loved the setup despite everything, with him trying to kill him, and it being right after he found out he was a Nour. The signs and the universe are really threatening to pull them apart; they still fuck, with Boss's tall ass smacking the light and the best part of all: KEN COVERING JAMES EYES BECAUSE HE IS ASHAMED OF HIM READING HIM AND SEEING THAT HE'S A NOUR. YALL, I NO JOKE THINK ABOUT THIS SCENE EVERY GOD DAMN DAY, BECAUSE HOLY SHIT. LOVED THAT DETAIL.
Another thing that I really liked was the slow dancing. I feel like it was a nice blast from the past to help with Ken’s lore about how the house he lives in is the bar he used to frequent, and I just love everything about it. Them holding each other and Ken crying fuckkkk. I loved that. I also liked how we connected back to it at the end of the show; lowkey loved.
I loved the titles of all of the episodes. I don't think I even really appreciated it until the final couple of episodes, but that was a good addition to this already really good show.
The first thing that comes to mind when thinking about dislikes is the whole thing with the dad and the house fire. I didn't really want to put that here, but it lowkey felt very random in the plotline. Like they were really pushing it at the start, and I mean, that is what the introduction is showing: his house burning and his dad dying, but we didn't really get any lore other than that. Like, we thought Ken killed him, and then we thought Chita killed him, but we don't even really know because all we saw was the rainbow on the head, so we are just mad at the entire Nour race? How does that make any sense?
I needed more with the true love thing at the end. Okay, so James doesn't quite die, and he is in this weird limbo that sends him back to when Ken first died (also I wish he went through all of his deaths in the limbo, but I also understand that that would have been doing WAY too much). Ken's true love his crying over Ken's body and turns him into a Nour. Then he dies (which I also still don't understand why, because how does that even work if Chita turning Jira into a Nour didn't kill him), and the soulmate and James both have that white glow and also the same build and face, so does that mean James is his soulmate? So if he is, why didn't Ken recognize him at first? I don't know because they didn't tell us, so I was left with more questions than answers for that, which I wasn't very fond of.
I wanted more with the ending, but I really don't know what. I now have an empty hole in my stomach as I think about all of the people who have died with no one to care for them, no one to even notice they have lived for 200 years because no one ever cared in the first place. I am forever heartbroken, my lord. "I don't know what I was expecting for the ending, but it was definitely not our side couple fucking dying. That was a lot. I wanted more, but I also don't know if I could handle more. But yeah, holy shit. I'm at a loss for words right now. This was really phenomenal, and I think they did a really good job with this. I'm so gagged right now."
Questions (something new for shows that have supernatural elements in them):
1. Can Nours have kids?
2. If Nours die and wake up almost right away, then how do they change their identity if they are people near them during that death?
a. My example is when Ken shot himself in the military, like someone had to hear that gunshot and come looking, but he dies and wakes back up under a different name like what?
3. Is Chita the Nour that can kill Nours because he was killed by a Nour? But Jira was too, so wouldn't that also make him a Nour that can kill Nours? I'm very lost.
4. Also, if Chita could kill himself this whole time, why hadn't he done it before already?
5. Before Ken started working at the hospital or as an inspector, where did he get all of his blood? Like for the past 200 years, where did he get his blood?
6. What happened to Chita's original man? Like, did Chita kill him or what?
7. Can you have more than one true love?
My episode overview (just quotes I thought were relevant to the plot or funny that I put in my reviews! Episode 1: "HOW HAS IT BEEN 200 YEARS AND WE ARE STILL POOR." Episode 2: "I’m hooked and feeling a little crazy." "THAT'S WHY HE WAS TYPING ON THE COMPUTER, WEIRD. I’m like, why are we so close to the computer screen, typing like a moron?" Episode 3: "I like how we think. Just shoot it." "We are kissing again… this junk is addicting, and I'm gonna lose my mind waiting for this." Episode 4: "THEY WERE GETTING INTO THAT AND THIS BITCHES TALL ASS KEPT HITTING THE FAN. ALSO, OH MY GOD, HIM COVERING HIS EYES SO HE COULDN'T SEE HE WAS A NOUR WHEN THEY WERE FUCKING, I'M ACTUALLY SICK." " PRAYING OUR SIDE COUPLE HAS PLOT ARMOR BECAUSE I WILL BE SICK IF ONE OF THEM DIES, OH MY GOD." Little did I know. Episode 6: " I'm in love with these two, especially in the beaters! IM GONNA JUMP." " You are my only friend because all of our other friends have gotten murdered…Also, the brother only kissed his friend because he saw his brother Chita kissing, bruh. He did not know that was an option." Episode 7: "I KNEW IT HAD TO BE SOMEONE WE HAVE ALREADY MET, BUT I WAS NOT FUCKING EXPECTING CHITA. LIKE WHAT? I AM ACTUALLY SO GAGGED." Episode 8: "CHITA HAS KILLED EVERY PERSON THAT HAS DIED IN THIS SHOW, AND I'M GAGGED." "I'm like, why the fuck is her arm backward? Because they blew that shit off. That's why her arm is backward. He fully got his spine snapped in half. I was wondering why he was slumped over, but I didn't wanna question the small details. Should have questioned it." Episode 9: "We have had 200 goddamn years to think about it, and now we are changing our mind." Episode 10: "Wow. I'm so glad we have plot armor!…oh." "ALSO WHY WOULD WE EVER GO BACK TO WORK? Like in what world? I will be jobless for the rest of my life after this shit." " Imagine if James killed himself, and then Ken spent the rest of his days looking for him. I think I would have dropped the show. Thinking about that is making me very sad." "I'M NOT OKAY, I'm too INVESTED, I'm not okay, I'm not okay. Holy fucking shit, that was the longest 56 minutes of my life. I'm going to die in this house."
I am at a loss for words. I would 100% recommend this, and I actually thought this was really well written, and the more you think about it, the sadder you are gonna get. I am not even into supernatural shit like that, but I would rewatch this over and over again. Okay bye!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Women's Empowerment? Yes. Romance? No.
The biggest problem with this drama is the main character, Xu Lanxiang. She is a "Mary Sue" for lack of a better term with skewed motivations and confusing actions. She seems unaffected by her biological family's deaths unless or until the plot requires it. It gets to the point where her identity as Shen Jialan is only relevant to explain why she's so good at everything. Towards the middle, she exchanges all of her charisma for stoicism that's simply not enjoyable to watch. And throughout the entire second half, her feelings towards Lin Jinqi are inconsistent. She goes from the silent treatment, to risking her life to save his, to confessing they're not compatible, to consummating their marriage. Even after they have children, she goes from doting wife to literally saying "one lifetime" with him is enough. It's just confusing and quite frankly exhausting; and can we please get my man Liu Xueyi in a historical drama that doesn't turn his character into a complete simp? The female friendships are wonderfully written, but the romances really are not. It's possible for a woman to be inspiring while also being in love 😭Was this review helpful to you?
Very Poorly Acted Drama
I noticed quite a few folks saying that this was some kind of new twist on the "vampire theme". I really beg too differ. This had nothing too do with being "vampiric" besides the drinking blood aspect. More importantly as with any drama i watch the story is key with me. And this story was all over the place. I found the pacing was terrible, and the acting wasn't much better. The actors were laughing and joking one minute and then trying too be serious in another scene. It's almost if they were forcing their emotions. That's what i mean by it was all over the place. I watched My Golden Blood which was a good vampire themed drama. In fact, it's probably one of the best out there at least right now. I encourage everyone too give that one a watch. And it was also FAR better acted and had an actual story behind it. However, the ending too "Nour" was done terribly. I was BY FAR more into Chita and the doctor's love story than the main characters. And those two actors could act...!!! I've been watching Asian BL's for the better part of 25yrs now. And this just isn't one i can recommend in good faith.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
NOUR is what I wanted a dark Thai fantasy BL to bwe
I went into NOUR expecting another supernatural BL with an interesting premise, attractive leads, mystery, romance, and hopefully some decent atmosphere. What I did not expect was to become this invested in the actual story.For me, NOUR is one of those dramas where the premise and the execution actually work together. The supernatural elements are not simply there to make the romance look more dramatic. The mystery, characters, relationships, atmosphere, and fantasy world all feel connected to each other.
That is what made NOUR stand out to me.
I have watched GMMTV's Revamp and My Golden Blood, so I naturally found myself comparing them with NOUR. All three play with supernatural ideas and romance, but my biggest problem with those dramas was that I could often see the potential of what they were trying to be more clearly than what actually appeared on screen.
With NOUR, I don't feel that way.
THE STORY ACTUALLY FEELS LIKE A STORY
This is probably my biggest compliment.
NOUR does not feel as though the supernatural concept was created first and the plot was built around it afterward. The mystery gives the characters something meaningful to investigate, while the supernatural side gradually becomes part of the larger picture.
I genuinely wanted to know what was going on.
There were questions I wanted answered, connections I wanted to understand, and characters whose pasts made me curious. Even when the drama deliberately kept information from the audience, I felt that there was a reason for it.
That made me keep watching because I wanted to understand the world, not simply because I wanted to see the next romantic scene.
THE PLOT TWISTS
And then there are the plot twists.
This is probably the part I enjoyed most about NOUR.
The drama does not simply throw in a twist for shock value and then move on. The revelations actually change how you look at what happened earlier. Information that initially seems insignificant starts making sense later, and certain characters and events take on a completely different meaning once the truth is revealed.
That is exactly the kind of storytelling I enjoy.
I like when a drama makes me question what I think I already understand. NOUR repeatedly gave me that feeling of, "Wait, so that's what was actually happening?"
More importantly, the twists do not feel completely disconnected from the story. They are tied to the characters, the supernatural mythology, and the mystery that the drama has been building.
This is where I think NOUR separates itself from My Golden Blood and Revamp for me.
Those dramas had interesting supernatural premises, but I often felt that the potential of the premise was greater than the actual storytelling. With NOUR, the mystery itself kept me engaged. I was not simply waiting for the next romantic scene. I was trying to work out what was really happening.
Even when I thought I had figured something out, the drama could make me reconsider it.
That made watching each episode much more satisfying.
I also appreciate that the twists are not only about "Who is the villain?" or "What supernatural creature is this?" The better revelations are connected to the characters and their relationships, which gives them emotional weight.
So for me, the biggest strength of NOUR is not simply that it has twists.
It is that the story gives those twists somewhere to go.
The revelations affect the way you understand the characters and the story itself. That makes the mystery feel worthwhile rather than something added purely to keep viewers watching.
And honestly, that was one of the main reasons I found myself thinking about NOUR after an episode ended.
THE ATMOSPHERE
This is another area where NOUR impressed me.
It has a darker, more serious atmosphere that suits its story incredibly well. The foggy setting, mystery, supernatural elements, investigation, and sense of danger all contribute to the same mood.
This is where I think NOUR has an advantage over a lot of fantasy BLs.
It actually feels like a supernatural mystery drama that happens to contain romance, rather than a romance drama that happens to contain supernatural elements.
That distinction matters.
THE CHARACTERS
James and Ken were the biggest reason I stayed invested.
Their relationship does not feel completely straightforward. There is mystery surrounding Ken, there are things James does not understand, and there is a sense that their connection is tied to something much bigger than a simple attraction between two people.
I especially liked that the characters have their own problems and motivations outside the romance.
The second couple also contributes to the story rather than feeling like a completely separate BL that was inserted to fill screen time.
That made the whole drama feel more like an actual ensemble story.
THE ROMANCE
I also appreciate that the romance is not treated as something completely separate from the main plot.
James and Ken's relationship is complicated by the mystery surrounding them, which makes their interactions more interesting to me. There is curiosity, uncertainty, attraction, distrust, and emotional tension.
I prefer this kind of relationship over a romance where the characters immediately become emotionally dependent on each other simply because they are the main couple.
There is something to discover about both of them.
And that makes their relationship much more interesting.
MY GOLDEN BLOOD AND REVAMP
I want to be clear that I don't dislike My Golden Blood or Revamp simply because I prefer NOUR.
Actually, that is why the comparison is interesting.
Both My Golden Blood and Revamp had concepts that immediately caught my attention. They had supernatural worlds, established BL pairings, attractive production concepts, and plenty of potential.
But I often found myself thinking, "This could have been so much better if the story had fully used its potential."
With NOUR, I don't have that same frustration.
NOUR feels more confident about what kind of drama it wants to be.
It does not constantly remind me that I am watching a BL. It lets the mystery exist. It lets the characters exist. It lets the supernatural elements carry some weight. And when the romance develops, it feels like part of the story rather than the entire reason the story exists.
That is probably the biggest difference for me.
My Golden Blood gave me the feeling of watching a very promising supernatural BL.
Revamp gave me the feeling of watching a promising idea that did not always reach its potential.
NOUR gives me the feeling of watching the drama I originally wanted those concepts to become.
That is why I am enjoying NOUR so much.
FINAL THOUGHTS
NOUR is not perfect. There are moments where the story can feel complicated, and I can understand why some viewers may find the supernatural mythology confusing.
But personally, I would rather watch a drama that gives me something to think about than one that explains everything immediately and leaves me with nothing to wonder about.
What I appreciate most is that NOUR respects its own story.
It has a dark atmosphere, an interesting supernatural concept, a mystery that actually makes me curious, characters with their own motivations, plot twists that genuinely change how I view the story, and a romance that grows naturally out of the larger narrative.
After watching supernatural BLs like My Golden Blood and Revamp, NOUR feels especially satisfying because it shows how much better these concepts can work when the writing, atmosphere, character relationships, and world-building are all pulling in the same direction.
For me, NOUR is not simply another supernatural BL.
It is the kind of drama that makes me think, "Yes. This is what I wanted."
Was this review helpful to you?
*This* is what a vampire BL should be!
First things first: This is definitely *not* a 'brain-off' type of series-- there are a number of things that are (purposefully) not *explicitly* spelled out/explained in detail; viewers need to pay close attention to everything-- and I actually rather loved that. There is of course a place for shows that are less analysis-intensive, and I do enjoy those, too; however (particularly in this unfortunate era of no-attention-spans and dismal-media-literacy, where a lot of show writers have apparently just given up and are not only explicitly spelling everything out but are then practically beating people over the head with it ad infinitum as well 😅) I really, *really* like when a show actually trusts its audience enough to let its viewers either figure out or infer things on their own. And, IMO, Nour did this quite well. 👍 So, while I can understand why some viewers might have wanted more solid detail on certain points, personally I actually really enjoyed that aspect of the writing here.As for the show itself: This series combines romance, crime procedural, and (a different, very interesting version of) vampires into one great package, topped off by *fantastic* acting. (Actor Tongtong {who plays the main protagonist}, in particular, was a revelation-- and the way he uses his eyes {and other microexpressions, too, but the *eyes* in particular} is just *incredible.*)
The main protagonist is very sympathetic, and I really liked the personality of his love interest (who is not only a reckless, impulsive gremlin {lol} but is actually also very intelligent, both in terms of pure smarts *and* in EQ-- which is not really all that common in characters with his archetype, at least in current BL). (I would talk about the other two couples as well, but I feel that it's best to go into this without much commentary on either of them, as they sort of balance out the narrative in ways that are too involved for a general review.)
In terms of the vampire lore, I really liked how the writers both removed some and then added some of their own little details to previously-existing lore to make it a little more unique, and also that they very much emphasized the actual *horror* of vampirism, and the reality of it often being a curse more than it's a blessing as well. (Adding to this, IMO it was genius how they incorporated a couple of other general {not-vampire-specific} folktale/fairytale tropes into this in a slightly-twisted way, too! 👍)
The show also explores several different very interesting themes (along with parallels and contrasts between those themes via the different characters), including (among other things) some beautiful commentary on selfish vs. selfless love, and a great full-circle bookend for the main protagonist. (I've also seen some discussions elsewhere on how the arcs for the characters seem to be very in-line with Buddhist teachings, which-- given the fact that the creators of this show specifically wanted to make vampires that are distinct to Thailand, and Buddhism plays a big part in Thai culture-- should definitely be taken into account when processing the outcomes of certain characters' fates. In this regard, IMO all of the main characters got *precisely* the endings that made the most sense given their past actions and character arcs.)
(Do note for content/trigger warnings' sake though that the topic of suicide-- both attempted and actually committed 😅-- does play a large part throughout all 4 main characters' arcs as well, so please be sure to be in a good/safe headspace first before watching! 🙏)
Now, all that said: This wasn't perfect-- yes, there were a few small moments of editing-disjointedness, and perhaps a little plot or pacing hitch here and there-- however, overall, I really commend the show's creators (and actors-- they put their *all* into this!) for not only creating an excellent vampire show, a great BL, and a show that makes you think all rolled into one, but also for doing something that is very unusual nowadays (and which was, quite frankly, very refreshing). I will absolutely be rewatching this, and I heartily recommend it! 👍
Was this review helpful to you?
deeply emotional, realistic modern drama that tackles heavy themes of trauma
the story centers on Ye Sibei (Mao Xiao Tong), an ordinary working woman whose life is upended by a traumatic personal crisis and systemic injustice. As her marriage faces its ultimate trial, her steadfast husband, Qin Nan (Vin Zhang), stands as her anchor, refusing to let her suffer in silence. Together, they fight to rebuild their lives, seek justice, and find hope amidst painful circumstances.Was this review helpful to you?
An energetic, modern romance drama
When heiress Xiang Yuan (Janice Wu) takes on a challenge to save a struggling regional subsidiary of her family's corporate empire, she unexpectedly crosses paths with her former high school crush, Xu Yanshi (Vin Zhang). Now working as a brilliant navigation engineer facing workplace roadblocks, Yanshi and Xiang Yuan navigate corporate politics, career ambitions, and unresolved feelings in this charming romantic comedy.Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Wow, Interesting
A woman's journey this is what this drama really was - her life of privelage and no worries only about her marriage and what's he going to look like etc., Then tragedy hits and oh, boy it hits hard. Her new life, can she overcome the hardship and she does with flying colors. The only thing she wants and could ask for is her freedom. Women aren't allowed to be free and live without a man or have any type of freedom not until another 200 yrs. So we could all kind of guess what happens. Keep watching because it is all worth it ( When you see that slap) She grew to love and respect the situation she was in. She helps many women along the way. Thank you for this journey. Sometimes we forget that many women have paved the way for modernization.Women could not freely choose their spouse
A woman’s personal feelings were not the deciding factor. Who care's how they feel.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Overall - It's a Bit Much
A complete review after watching the entire series:I enjoyed this series up until the 9th episode, and then it became work to watch it. I did finish it but not without some reservations. My pros and cons of this series:
Pros:
1. Kang Hyung Suk - I've seen him in other series and always liked him as an actor. In my opinion, he stole the series. It was a layered storyline, and he equaled this by bringing layers to his character. Having always seen him as the good guy, he took on the role of the devious, demented bad guy who acted like everyone's hero/supporter but in truth was diabolical. He did this really, really well. Kudos to Hyung Suk!!
2. The Storyline - The story had layers. There was a lot of twists and turns that kept the viewer engaged. While this was a strength, it also brought a weakness. You can read that part below.
3. The Characters - the two main leads had chemistry, as did the secondary couple. They also brought a high-quality visual element to the story. It was nice just to watch them. I loved the storyline of the brother/sister twins traveling through time. So many series has the brother as a hapless, lazy character that is just annoying to the female lead. But this brother was an integral part, not only to the main storyline, but to his sister as well, and I thought this was refreshing. The trio of good friends, Ha Na, Ha Ru, Woo Jae was a big strength of the whole story, and I don't think it would have been as good without the friendship of these three.
4. The Production - when the series ends, stay for the photos of the production crew doing their job. I think most of time, we have no idea what it takes to put on these dramas, and these photos will show you how hard everyone works.
Cons:
Why I titled this "a bit much."
1. The Storyline - I got lost in the details of the time traveling back and forth, and I think this is why around episode 9, it felt like work to watch it. I had a hard time keeping straight whether they were in the present or the past. This might be a good series to binge all at once so you can keep things straight.
The "bit muches" of the main couple:
They seemed to like to do scenes in bed---with all their clothes on---it felt awkward and unnecessary. We get that they are in love and devoted to each other, but to validate this with every other scene was too much. This is honestly the first drama series where I stated out loud to the tv "enough with the kissing!!" The proposal on the beach was not a surprise and to me didn't actually feel natural to these characters, nor something I think the viewer necessarily needed to wrap up the story.
The slow motion scenes were exhausting to watch. Whether it as more kissing, or the slow motion injury/dying scenes, it got exhausting and boring.
As good as the storyline was, with all the details and layers, I still was able to figure out some key plot twists. I knew from the first time they traveled back to the past who the bad guy was. So it was no surprise to me when that was finally revealed. So the storyline with Hyeong Won was boring and unnecessary.
2. Unnecessary Stuff
The thrown in characters and plot twists that didn't make sense and didn't go anywhere:
The bloody package delivered to Ha Na. Was this a bird? Or something else? I never quite understood the point of this.
Speaking of birds, I never got the connection between the birds and Jun Mo's obsession with Ha Na.
Hyeong Won's character - the pretend bad guy that isn't
The twins father played two roles, and it was mentioned but never explained--what was that??
Ye Rang's other boyfriend--was this really necessary?
The Fairy with the Camcorder--so this was suppose to explain where the time traveling camcorder came from, but I think it left more questions than answers.
Woo Jae's father - I'm not sure this character and his blackmailing was really necessary other than to establish how demented Jun Mo was.
3. Unnatural and Non-human behavior - One of my pet peeves in dramas is putting human beings in situations where they do not act natural. Unfortunately, to keep this drama moving forward, there was a lot of it. The unusualness of the behavior just spoils the plot twist and can be annoying to the viewer. A big one came at the end of the series when Jun Mo's character was standing on the edge of a building seemingly about to jump off, but Ha Na and Woo Jae talked him out of it. He turns, still standing on the edge, and Ha Na moves toward him and reaches out her hand. A woman who had been stalked, almost killed, had loved ones killed by this person, would not in anyway shape or form walk towards this person and reach out her hand. Very unrealistic!! Not only that but I said out loud, "He's going to grab her and fling her off the building." Of course that is what happens, of course he grabs her and bends her over the edge, but she (in slow motion) remembers a judo maneuver and flips him over her shoulder, where they are now about 6 feet from the edge of the building----like wtf!!!
I've stated this before with other dramas. It starts out great, tanks in the middle, redeems itself in the ending episode. It's a good watch, you just need to take notes to keep all the details and characters straight.
A Time-Traveling Tale of Body-switching Twins - the review I wrote after watching the first 4 episodes
A little bit Lovely Runner with a tad The Kings Affection thrown in and we have a tale about a brother/sister twin duo who get to time-travel back to their high school days to save a friend. The catch is when they travel back, they switch places. So it makes for a multitude of awkward moments between those they interact with, especially their friend Yoo Jae who has a crush on the sister but is inexplicably drawn to the twin brother and doesn't know what to make of it.
Much like Lovely Runner, each attempt back in time seems to change little and even hurts one or both of the twins in their future life. There is also this mystery bad guy (added note - I knew at this point who it was) who is trying to harm Ha Na, but keeps killing Yoo Jae instead.
So far it's keeping my attention, and I've grown to enjoy the characters. The plot of undoing the future by traveling back in time thanks to a video camcorder, switching bodies, and this mysterious bad guy has peaked my interest enough, I'm looking forward to the next episode. I hope it will stay interesting. My advice, at least at this point (after 4 episodes) is to give it a go.
Was this review helpful to you?
Ugh. What was that?!
So, I never thought a drama with these leads would get an 8 on a drama, but that's exactly what this drama deserves, The story and premise had so much potential, but it quickly became a scowl fest from both leads. I thought their chemistry could carry the show, but it never developed past childhood friend-zone. The bad guys fell flat. The secondary characters had better acting direction than the leads. The emperor was unnecessary. The pacing and lighting were weird. It felt like a puzzles that decided to paste the non-fitting pieces together and just cut the bits that didn't fit. Will not be recommending.Was this review helpful to you?
Better titled, "Confessions..."
Melo Movie has well-conceived characters and a cinematic context that should have created a lot more consequence and drama, but the characters all suffer from the malady of failure to communicate. As a result, the interesting parts get told in hindsight, when the series is ready to wrap up its threads. If you like drama told as a podcast, this series will fit the bill.Told with excellent actors who are slightly underutilized, Melo Movie addresses Romance, Regret, Philosophy, Ambition, Death, Life, and Love—all the good stuff—with restraint and care.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A darker, mystical and bitterweet series!
Not comepletly spoiler free (but I try to keep it minimal).What makes Nour special to me is how it balances the thriller (like) and mystical aspects with deep, character driven moments. The show isn't afraid to give its characters breathing room. Seeing them share quiet moments or experience the heavy psychological strain of their live actually makes them feel natural, and those moments of decompression are what keep the high stress situations grounded.
The heart of the series (imo) is the dynamic between James and Ken. Ken isn't your average officer, and his personal existential mission (which naturally shifts his priorities) is greatly portrayed. Their relationship has a lot of hidden connections (only partly shown until the end) and really kept me on my toes. I think the acting across the board is fantastic, bringing real emotional weight to the mystical stakes, and the chemistry between the leads completely sells the intense romance. While it deals with dark themes and supernatural rules, things fit together within its own unique world. This isn't just true for thethe leads, but also for characters like Dr. Jirat and Chita, who share great chemistry and sad past as well.
I really like the concept of the Nour and the love connection tied to it. While it’s clearly inspired by "traditional" vampires, it has its own unique traits and rules, making it feel somewhat familiar yet surprisingly different.
I personally loved this series, the characters, and the acting, as well as the world building and the occasional funny breaks that lighten the mood. I even appreciate the bittersweet ending and the parts that are left open to interpretation! I would really recommend the show if you enjoy a slightly darker theme and mystic elements mixed with a spiritual and supernatural world.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
One story, two narratives
I liked this series a lot and I was fully engaged. Yet it left me wanting more.The story is kind of tropey but engaging. The production value is high and acting is solid. I can’t help but feel the show has squandered some of its potential.
Let’s take a step back. The first EP is intense. We are usually given time to get familiar with the multitude of characters. Instead, we are given a SparkNotes summary by a younger version FL and her mother on their carriage ride home. Then the proverbial hits the fan and we are watching an extinction level event before the end credit rolls. To say our FL lives in a harsh and unjust world is an understatement.
Our FL went from a noble lady to a slave/maid overnight. She can only count on her wits to survive. Much of the show is based on her struggles spanning years. We watch her thrive and forms a band of sisters who become her core supporters.
On the opposite corner is a cadre of female nemeses. Most are driven by typical motivations like jealousy, greed and/or social status. They are mostly one dimensional except the ML's ex-wife and Zheng Manyi. They are strong characters and embodied a lot of the resentments against the established hierarchy. They are willing to take their destiny into their own hands, come what may.
Oh, I mustn't forget the palace intrigues and foreign invasions. For once, these storylines are not the main game. We are spared the drawn-out machinations and I am thankful. Their sudden impact is no less devastating though.
In their place, the show parades a series of parables and dress them up as challenges for our FL. To be fair, she is intelligent and quick witted. She has a strong moral compass. We watch her growth with anticipation.
Let's face it, the whole feudal, patriarchal, Confucian system was never about equality. The whole Three Obedience and Four Virtues mantra is designed to shackle a female to a male and curtail her rights.
In this case, our FL did good, but that required her to work within the system rather than against it.
My problem is that I kept thinking she is destined for bigger things, yet the glass ceiling is real. Our dear writer has a lot to say about gender inequality and other horrible things like slavery and the arbitrariness of the "justice" system, but everything is handled with a light touch.
I find that frustrating until I realised this show actually has two narratives.
One is obviously the story centred on our FL, and by extension, our OTP. That mostly runs true. It is a super slow burn through until EP.37 (of 47) when the FL finally overcomes all her misgivings. Even after that turning point, the romance is still low key with minimal PDA.
The second narrative is our dear writer's desire to expose social issues in ancient China. It is a noble sentiment. There are multiple expositions where characters spell out a particular issue. They will commiserate with each other while calling out the injustice. Yet, the drama offers no solutions, just gentle reminders not to repeat these mistakes.
This frustrates me. The show builds up the FL as a wise and forthright person so let her lead the charge. Enough with the parables. Build the barricades! Viva la revolución!
Inner peace . . . Inner peace . . .
In terms of acting, it is solid. There are so many support characters. Most earn their keep. The senior actors are all outstanding. I do find the ML a bit too low key. He is kind and gentle to the FL and stays true to her unto the bitter end. There are not many scenes where he can truly shine.
Needless to say, 7-10 is in her element. She is the queen of girl-to-woman roles. She is one of few actors who can convincingly play a teenager and then morph into a mature woman over time. Tan is the soul of this series. I enjoyed her performance; I find her too serene at times though.
This leaves me with a conundrum. Act 1 is very good. Act 2 does drag a bit when she is roleplays a wife. The show found its mojo in Act 3. However, some of the later subplot are a bit lose as they rush to tie up all the loose ends. The bittersweet ending certainly left its mark.
OBTW, there are lots of time skips in this drama. The director uses several clever tricks and motifs to signify the passage of time. I also like the cinematography. Some scenes are very artistically pleasing.
I enjoyed this series overall. I fell in love with it during Act 1. Then the slow burn/low yield romance tested my patience. The constant reminder of the woman's lot left me either hugging or hitting my therapy teddy.
In the end, it is a good Chinese Cinderella story with bonus parables. I like it a lot, I just stop short of loving it. Peace.
Was this review helpful to you?
Deliciously Twisted
I loved this. I went into it highly anticipating the release, and it did not disappoint. I thought it was a really nice blend of folklore and customs with a story centered around revenge and deceit. At its core, there was a mystery that slowly unfolded, and I really enjoyed watching how everything came together and how the different themes blended into one cohesive story. It kept the drama engaging and prevented the narrative from ever feeling flat.I also liked how confusing it could be at times—not because it was difficult to follow, but because the storyline wasn't always easy to predict. Even when you thought you had things figured out, it could still leave you wondering whether you had completely misread the situation. Characters were constantly manipulating one another, and it wasn't always clear who you could actually trust. Trying to figure out who the real villain was among all the other characters added another layer of intrigue. I enjoy when a drama doesn't make everything so easy to guess because it keeps me invested in what happens next.
Even though the premise revolves around scamming people and using folklore and props to fabricate certain events, the drama still maintained a darker tone. That gave it a chilling atmosphere that I thought worked especially well as a fall watch. The timing of its release felt fitting.
Overall, I rate this very highly.
Was this review helpful to you?



