When the Stars Gossip

Flies, feelings and Zero gravity

This show is an ambitious blend of science fiction, drama, and absurdity—sometimes brilliant, other times baffling. The premise has potential: a space mission tackling groundbreaking experiments like flies mating in zero gravity, mouse surgeries, and human embryos developing to the morula stage. How they managed all this in five days is anyone’s guess—it took humanity decades to achieve a fraction of this!The $500 billion lottery win and sperm-egg fusion without microscope are the cherries on this over-the-top cake.All in a 5-day tourism package..
Moving on , For science enthusiasts, The concept of flies naturally mating in space for the first time could spark curiosity. But for others, waiting 20 minutes for this to happen might feel like a slog. The exaggerated timeline, while entertaining in its audacity, stretches believability to its breaking point.

The characters are a mixed bag. The FL is a rule-abiding nerd whose rigidity overshadows any warmth she might have brought to the role. The ML, played by Minho, feels miscast—not his fault, but the role doesn’t align with his usual charm. Park Hyung Sik might have been a better fit. The supporting cast brings their own share of chaos: alcoholic aunts, a control-obsessed conglomerate uncle, and a partner embroiled in infidelity. Their tangled personal lives often feel forced, overshadowing the core plot.

That said, the show does attempt to explore interesting themes. It delves into scientific curiosity, ethical dilemmas, and human emotions under extraordinary circumstances. If you can overlook the occasional (okay, frequent) logical leaps, there’s a quirky charm to its audacity.

As a longtime K-drama fan, I couldn’t help but notice the Netflix-isation of this show. The emotional depth and aesthetic simplicity that defined classic K-dramas are missing. Instead, we get forced alcoholism and a bizarrely out-of-place soft porn-esque scene in the first episode, which detracts from the narrative. This shift in tone may appeal to some but alienates traditional fans.

In summary, the show is bold and unique, though uneven in its storytelling. It’s worth a watch if you’re open to a mix of scientific curiosity and wild plot twists, but you’ll need to suspend disbelief and embrace the chaos. For fans of traditional K-dramas, this might not hit the same sweet spot, but it’s an interesting experiment nonetheless.

Read More

Is WTSG an Allegory?

Perhaps WTSG is an allegory, where events and characters represented specific ideas or abstractions. (Also, farce can be an important component of allegory, as was on ample display in WTSG).

I think allegory is lost on us inhabitants of the 21st century. Allegory is complex and uncomfortable. We like quick and easy. Instagram, TikTok - all types of social media - cannot begin to understand allegory.

A Kdrama like WTSG can try to use allegory as the narrative arc, but in doing so gets roundly booed and robustly hated. Especially when we all went into this drama thinking it was going to be a feel good, HEA romcom.

The story was full of plot holes and inconsistencies, but I'm not sure if it was a script problem or an editing room problem. Dialog and footage that ended up on the cutting room floor might have actually helped viewers better understand the characters' goals, motivations, conflicts, etc.

For example, I would have preferred that the Lee Min Ho character went on the mission under different circumstances, secretive, yes, but not outright illegal or unethical. The fact that he was doing something illegal made him immediately less sympathetic. But maybe the intent was that his character especially was meant to make us, as viewers, think a little more deeply about ethics, by that I mean what people ought to do, or which behavior is morally right. Ethics is not a scientific in nature, it is philosophical.

All in all, though, I 100% enjoyed the drama.

P.S. I think the OST (the 8 songs) is one of the best examples of songs and lyrics that match the overall themes and ideas of the drama.

Read More

Zero chemestry, worst drama that I ever whach

no chemistry between any characters. no connection between them, effectively nothing connects in this drama. everything seems unrealistic in a good way, new subject and comical sometimes, so many good actors in one show... I was so curious ... but you don't get with anything, you don't learn anything, you don't hope for anything. I kept hoping that would get better, but I've reached episode 8 and I'm terribly bored. I can't even see them kissing. everything is forced and toxic. no emotion, no connection, no feeling to convey to the public. ML and FL have nothing in common. I watched till there for LMH, that has a great acting in Pachinko and I really want to see him again in a new and diffrent kdrama. I hope for next one he will choose a good script that suits him and his talent and hope for a good chemestry with a FL. without chemistry you have nothing

Read More

Zero Gravity at It's Finest

This series was the highlight of my weekends while it aired. filled with entertainment
and sometimes I'm hanging off the coach lol. It had some things that are unusual
and thats why I found it so refreshing to watch. You need to have an open mind when
watching it. It's not the kind of Kdramas you can predict what is going to happen.
People who rate the series badly are simple not a genre for them but they still watched
it purely because of LMH, which many are his anti fans. Some only want to see the ML
in Dramas they can romantacise him but they did not get that with his character.
WTSG is not predictable and I find the story itself very original and made me think after.
I laughed, cried, screamed, jumped and was absorbing every bit of it while watching.
If a series can make me nearly fall off my sofa. It's a freaking good one.
The Space scenes were executed beautifully. I recommend you watch it and ignore the
bad rating and negative comments. Actually avoid reading the comments before you watch.

Read More

A Well-Directed but making you want to rewrite the script and send it back for reshoots

When the Stars Gossip is an ambitious series that showcases tremendous effort from the production team and a desire for innovation, steering away from clichés to appeal to an international audience. However, despite these efforts, the series ultimately fails on a large scale.

Why did it fail?
The series undeniably has many strong aspects and aimed for a grand scope, but it suffers from a major issue: a lack of clarity in its narrative purpose. It’s difficult to pinpoint exactly what When the Stars Gossip is trying to convey.

The story follows a romance between an astronaut and a gynecologist, but it also attempts to explore multiple other themes—without successfully tying them together. From the beginning, the series places itself in competition with top-tier dramas, raising expectations significantly.

Strong Performances but No Chemistry
The cast delivers impressive performances. Lee Min Ho surprises in a role that breaks away from his usual stereotype of the charming, wealthy romantic lead. He likely took on this risky project to challenge himself. Meanwhile, Gong Hyo Jin delivers a professional, natural performance that fits her character perfectly.
However, the couple lacks chemistry. Their relationship feels more like that of a married couple of 30 years rather than a fresh and passionate love story. This absence of spark makes it difficult for viewers to connect emotionally. he cool astronaut trio, which worked well and could have been truly endearing, faded away after episode 8. The Chaebol father, who played his role so well that I even started to 'like' him, had a satirical side that could have been even more striking and humorous.

An Internationally-Oriented Soundtrack
One of the strongest aspects of the series is its soundtrack. Featuring a strategic selection ranging from Hallyu pop-rock to hip-hop and classical music, the OST is clearly designed to appeal to a global audience.

A Well-Directed but Poorly Written Series
The director does an excellent job, and the production quality is commendable. Unfortunately, the real issue lies in the script.

The writer attempted to create an innovative story blending:
Science fiction, but not executed convincingly.
Themes of procreation and demographic challenges, relevant to aging populations in developed countries. This idea had great potential but ultimately falls apart due to logical inconsistencies.
Satirical comedy, which could have been a bold and effective choice—if fully committed to. However, the series oscillates between realism, comedy of absurdity, and serious drama without successfully uniting these tones.

As a result, the characters suffer from weak development. None are particularly engaging, and their actions often contradict their initial personalities. The love story escalates too quickly to be believable, and while the series raises profound philosophical and ethical questions, it fails to explore them meaningfully.

That said, episodes 7 and 8 stand out as particularly well-executed and engaging, proving that the series had the potential to succeed

A Misdirected and Misunderstood Project
Even the series’ promotional campaign was misleading. The teaser failed to accurately represent its tone, which may have contributed to the audience's confusion.

So...
Despite its flawed script and inconsistent narrative, This serie is still worth watching for its talented actors (10/10), the director’s efforts (9/10) , and the high production values. It raises thought-provoking questions about life, death, and the ethical limits of science. And making you want to rewrite the script and send it back for reshoots :)))

Read More

A funny comedy, but not only

First, everything looks like it takes place really in outer space, starting with mice movements and ending with the actors' ones. Second, it's very funny: I laughed a lot! The entire family barely waits to Sunday afternoon, when we can watch two episodes in a row. Third, both Gong Hyo-jin and Lee Min-ho have strong personalities on screen in general, and here there is no exception. During the last episodes, despite being interested in science and reading a lot about life outside Earth, I couldn't imagine a few weeks without gravitation can be so physically damaging, so this is also an eye opener.

It may not appeal to everyone, especially if you expected a drama instead of a comedy, but if you give it a chance, you may not be disappointed. I really love it!

Read More

we need 2016 drama back !! netflix stop plz get your hand off the kdrama

Netflix stop making kdrama!! everything was good until netflix entered to the world of kdrama ! we need 2016 drama back plz!
like whatthe he'll is going on with Lee min hoo to sign for such a ridiculous story!?
so meany critics about the scenario I don't wanna repeat other's idea but it's true the story is so stupid and ridiculous 🙄 +no chemistry between the cast .. disappointment 😞
lee min hoo I know this not your fault .. the cast is not going with the energy you r giving ..
I will keep giving chances to this show for lee min hoo only and I hope I dont give up

Read More

Not Good Enough

Korean Drama '' When the Stars Gossip '' is a space melodrama with a love story at its center.

First of all, the cinematography is impressive, and the zero-gravity scenes were well acted and filmed. The whole settings, costumes, and space scenes felt authentic and realistic as well.

Also, the middle part of the drama was quite enjoyable. The story has unfolded and the characters got better, with some suspense thrown into the mix to keep things interesting. The comedy part was also entertaining and carefully mixed with the rest of the genres.

However, the love story was not as great. It was oddly paced and it wasn't believable that they fell in love instantly when they arrived in space. The couple did have some cute scenes together in those episodes in the middle part of the drama, but, overall, it wasn't satisfying. The more mature scenes also didn't make sense due to the circumstances when it was 'conducted'.

Generally, the first episodes and the last episodes were really bad, as the story was all over the place, and it was hard to ignore the plot holes and nonsensical twists. Actually, and even though one should turn their brain off when watching this drama as the physical rules do not really apply, some things simply were too much.

Also, the ending was rushed, with a montage used to show what the time jumps robbed the audience of, and a lot of the side characters' stories were left unsolved.

Finally, all the performances were great by everyone in the cast.

So, overall, four out of ten.

Read More

This is a rant

Putting logic aside, I was really rooting for this rom-com until the final episode. The English name in no way prepares you for the mess of this drama. After the first 6-8 episodes, this drama was tolerable until the final episode. Overall, this drama reeks of propaganda and misogyny. Were the actors black-mailed to do this?

This show is polarizing. If you suffer from infertility or know any science - basic or a full blown astronaut - it's triggering. Even to the layman, it's unbelievable. The happy ending was there, they even shown us a glimpse of it, just to swerve left and jump off a bridge.

Issues/Opinions

1. Science without objectivity. The one good thing about this drama is that it can show how unchecked emotions/beliefs/etc. can ruin Science. Human beings are fallible in all that they do. One must take this into consideration in all things.

2. The science is not believable. I can explain further but I don't want to discuss the plot too much here.

4. With the creative liberties this drama took, it should have embraced the fantastical - went full on fantasy/anime.. in the world of Cowboy Bebop for example. That way the idea of humans having the technology to comfortably procreate in space would be more believable.

5. The whole premise was selfish. I understand wanting to be a mother but asking people to risk their lively-hoods and break international law was selfish and peak rich asshole entitlement.

6. The MOST triggering thing about this drama: "Counting your eggs before they hatch."

7. I read a review that this show was pro-life propaganda. I tried to rationalize it in another way but... yea. The themes of "having a child regardless of any consideration for said child and mother" is pro-life propaganda. Also, the "mother's sacrifice" propaganda. All the things the FL worked hard for an tried to preserve became not as important. It reinforces the ideology that women are only good for giving birth. I even agree with another user's review in that Eve's ending was probably recompense for destroying the morulas.

8. As someone who worked in labs, the way they disposed of biological material bothered me. No biological red bags or incineration. Not important but I noticed.

I liked the soundtrack but I liked Jin's song long before I watched the drama.

Read More

Subestimado

Agora que finalmente terminei o drama, vou dar uma opinião bem sincera: eu gostei muito.

Ele parte de uma premissa simples e objetiva, e o maior mérito da obra é justamente se manter fiel a ela do primeiro ao último episódio.

Tudo gira em torno da vida e da ideia de gerar: um médico obstetra, uma astronauta responsável por experimentos de reprodução de roedores no espaço, a fecundação secreta na estação espacial para que o sogro do protagonista continuasse sua linhagem, enfim, a trama nunca foge do que se propôs a discutir. Gerar é a base de tudo, e isso dá uma coesão muito bonita à narrativa.

Dentro disso, nada mais natural do que desenvolver um relacionamento entre o médico e a astronauta, o que acrescenta justamente a possibilidade de gerar vida no espaço também no plano humano. Eu gostei bastante de como essa relação foi construída. Ele é um personagem que nunca havia se apaixonado, e dividir um espaço tão íntimo e extremo com uma mulher tão dedicada, tão focada em criar e preservar a vida, acaba encantando ele. Ela, por sua vez, vive um tabu profissional ao se envolver com um turista espacial enquanto comandante, e as situações constantes de risco e quase-morte são fundamentais para despertar esse vínculo entre eles. Tudo isso fez sentido dentro do contexto.

O drama é muito gostoso de assistir. Tem um ritmo fácil, é acessível, não se perde em termos científicos nem tenta parecer mais inteligente do que é. Apesar de ser sci-fi, ele não foca em estudos técnicos, mas nas relações humanas. Acompanhar a rotina dos astronautas enquanto pessoas, convivendo, trabalhando, trocando experiências naquele ambiente tão específico, foi algo realmente prazeroso.

A mensagem do drama é bastante clara, até óbvia demais em alguns momentos, e eu nem concordo com ela. Mas, olhando como ficção, isso não me incomodou. Toda obra quer dizer alguma coisa, seja política, social ou emocional, e aqui o diretor escolheu passar a mensagem dele de forma direta. Eu gosto de assistir às coisas de forma crítica, e isso não me impede de aproveitar, pelo contrário, enriquece a experiência. Dá para perceber as intenções por trás de algumas falas e acontecimentos, especialmente quando lembramos da crise demográfica que a Coreia enfrenta hoje. Ainda assim, isso não estragou minha experiência, deu para discordar e, ao mesmo tempo, aproveitar personagens, diálogos e situações.

Um bom exemplo disso é a cena em que ela joga as mórulas fora e ele a chama de assassina. Eu discordo completamente da visão dele, mas o personagem foi construído exatamente para pensar assim. Ele é coerente consigo mesmo e com seu papel na história, e isso torna a cena válida dentro da lógica da narrativa.

Outro ponto forte é como o drama foi soltando pistas sutis desde o início sobre como tudo terminaria. O final não parece jogado, aleatório ou inventado às pressas, a história caminha para ele desde o começo, construindo aquele desfecho aos poucos.

Sinceramente, eu não entendo por que esse drama foi tão criticado. A trilha sonora é ótima, a fotografia é linda, os efeitos especiais são muito bem feitos e deixam tudo visualmente prazeroso. As cenas de tensão no espaço me deixaram com o coração na boca, e as cenas mais leves me fizeram rir à toa.

Ele não é complexo, não é profundo, mas também nunca prometeu ser. Isso não significa que seja vazio. Pelo contrário, achei interessante como o drama insere de forma natural aspectos reais das missões espaciais, a rotina, os exercícios diários por causa da perda de massa muscular, os enjoos, as sequelas físicas, inclusive ligadas à gravidez, sem transformar isso em algo técnico demais ou didático demais. São fatos reais inseridos com leveza, que enriquecem a trama sem sobrecarregar.

A química do casal é muito boa, e embora eu ache que o sentimento deles avançou rápido demais, relevei isso pelo contexto. Quando você confina pessoas em situações extremas, os sentimentos realmente se intensificam, basta ver como isso acontece até em realities como Big Brother.

Mesmo na simplicidade, os personagens conseguiram me emocionar, me fazer rir e até chorar (muito, em especial no último episódio).

Agora, se alguém me disser que se frustrou porque criou expectativas muito altas por causa da roteirista, eu entendo. Pelo peso do nome dela, esse realmente é um trabalho mais simples e modesto, poderia ter mais nuances, mais subentendidos, relações mais complexas. Mas claramente houve uma escolha do diretor por uma mensagem clara e uma narrativa linear. E, dentro dessa proposta, ele foi muito bem-sucedido.

No fim, é isso, um drama muito bom, coeso, linear, fiel à própria proposta e tecnicamente muito bem feito, que entrega exatamente o que promete, sem fingir ser algo que não é.

Read More