CostumeHEA

In my opinion, the drama is about 80% faithful to the novel, but by episode 11, it begins to diverge more while still maintaining significant similarities. One couple in the drama does not exist in the novel and was created specifically for the adaptation. The scenes in the drama are less violent compared to the novel, making the male lead (ML) appear softer and more romantic. However, the personalities and relationships of both the female lead (FL) and ML closely align with their counterparts in the novel. Additionally, the adaptation focuses on specific villains, whereas the novel addresses them more episodically. Overall, they are doing a commendable job with the adaptation.

His private business remains just that—private. It's no surprise that they often become paranoid; it seems that nearly everyone around them is ready to betray them for money or fleeting fame. The universe has a way of delivering karma, and it's only a matter of time. It infuriates me to witness how these actors are treated; they are human beings just like you and me. They hold jobs, portraying characters under the guidance of a director, and what we see on screen is merely a reflection of their craft—not their true selves.

For heaven's sake, let them be! They deserve their privacy and peace in real life. They own us nothing!

No.

I can't believe how much time you put into this. You're a true fan, and it's impressive.

Same old same old… I hate those endings.

**Episode 12 = Chapter 56 (Wordrain)**

**Spoilers Below…**
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.


The differences from the novel became more apparent in the Episode 11. Many “improper” scenes were removed due to Chinese censorship. The mountain portrayed in the novel was essentially a purgatory with different areas designated for various purposes: some for public unwanted boom boom, others for pregnant women, for baby deliveries, and for blood collection. What you saw in Episode 12 was is a very “soft” tv adaptation. In the novel, he killed everyone and destroyed the place.

In the novel, there is no love story between the snake and Mrs. Ye. Mrs. Ye (she was never the mistress of a sect, just a girl with an agenda) was killed, along with 99 other girls, very early in the book, while the snake remained just that—a snake. So nobody knows about their story even if is is obvious they will have a happy ending (production took many photos of the 2 couples). Their love story is inspired by the novel characters to please the tv audience. Having 2 couples is more popular early on in the series, so scriptwriter always adapt.

Yes, he did transform her into an otter. However, they didn’t admit their feelings until much later. They do become lovers in the next episode, and although he fell in love with her early on after she saved him during their encounters, they didn’t acknowledge their love right away. (I think the casting of FL and ML are very close to the novel)

It’s a sweet love story amidst a backdrop of death. Very happy ending.

Now it will all depends if production wanted 1 or 2 or even 3 seasons. Then open ending expected for S1.

We are not reading the same novel. Episode 12 is chapter 56 out of 166

There are many different factors to consider. Both dramas are highly rated (S+), which means they had high budgets. One drama features two very popular male and female leads, while the other does not. I personally have a soft spot for Arthur Chen and Xu Kai and like both FL so for me both dramas are equally enjoyable.

I remember her in "New Life Begins" and adored her baby face there. It seems that the Chinese standards for making actors and actresses thin have affected them as well.

To answer your question, I am watching both shows, and they are very different from each other. We shouldn't compare them like apples and oranges. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions about a drama, whether they like it or dislike it. Additionally, there are 4.7 billion people in Asia and millions of Western viewers who watch Asian dramas. Each of us has different cultures and tastes.

The ratings on kisskh (MDL) are just a small fraction compared to the wider viewership. For instance, "Moonlit" has over 300 votes, while "When Destiny Brings" has more than 600. A few fake accounts can easily skew the ratings on MDL. Moderators do not require a minimum time of membership to vote, which could help prevent disruptions in the ratings. However, a few hundred votes do not reflect the reality of these dramas. Their respective platforms indicate their huge popularity, showing a stark contrast between three-digit ratings and millions of viewers. MDL ratings do not accurately represent the true standing of these dramas.

Personally, I enjoy both shows.

Why can’t we share our opinions? Is there censorship among MDL members? This is a forum, and as long as we express our views respectfully, no one should prohibit our discussions here. This is not an exclusive fan forum. Name is kisskh, not MyDramaFanOnly. we are all members sharing our thoughts, whether they are positive or negative, about the show. Comparisons are common throughout the MDL platform.

Reviews are positive. It is on my watch list along with "Prisoner of Beauty" and two others. I prefer to watch when all episodes are completed, as I enjoy binge-watching them.

And now I have confirmation that we will have two happy love stories. Check the recent photos. 😉

WYDUWTATA? LOL
.
What? You don't understand what they are talking about? 😆 🤣😅
Thanks for asking, the big majority don't either… me included.

I was curious if and when the script would differ from the novel, and it is very obvious in Episode 10. The essence remains, but the details are different.

https://kisskh.at/discussions/693413-xian-yu/144236-calendar-airing-schedule

I’m really enjoying this adaptation! It stays quite true to the novel, with just a few changes to the characters and events. The casting is spot-on; both lead actors match my vision from the book perfectly. While there are a couple of minor post-production hiccups, they don’t detract from the overall experience. The acting is excellent, the plot is engaging, and the special effects are impressive. The fight choreography is well done, and the costumes and makeup are fantastic. Additionally, there's a lovely romance that adds to the charm of the drama. Overall, I'm having a wonderful time watching this show!

When picking a drama, I look at the actors’ filmography not to see their roles but to find out if they have been in dramas I liked. I dislike censorship and their prudish and homophobic restrictions. If the female lead is not childish, the male lead is mature enough, and the script keeps me engaged, then I’m usually satisfied. However, the reality is often different.

I tend to stick to my own preferences and rarely let ratings influence my choices. I usually read the synopses—even if they aren't well written—and watch the first episode to decide whether to continue watching. It's quite rare for me to follow a currently airing drama or participate in forums or comments; I've only done this with three dramas so far. I don't have a strong preference for whether the dramas are new or old, but I do avoid certain actors or actresses that annoy me. I generally prefer completed dramas, as I have little patience. I often find myself getting bored mid-drama, as very few keep me engaged. Lol.

To minimize the amount of space used in comments, I use the spoiler button

Same here. I also use Kisshk, but the subtitles aren't the best. Still, it's better than nothing.