Quantcast

Details

  • Last Online: 2 hours ago
  • Gender: Female
  • Location: hell
  • Contribution Points: 298 LV3
  • Birthday: March 30
  • Roles: VIP
  • Join Date: February 7, 2013
  • Awards Received: Finger Heart Award292 Flower Award676 Coin Gift Award140 Golden Tomato Award13 Reply Goblin Award16 Dumpster Fire Award18 Lore Scrolls Award12 Spoiler-Free Captain Award3 Cleansing Tomato Award10 Drama Bestie Award33 Emotional Support Commenter6 Comment of Comfort Award16 Hidden Gem Recommender1 Conspiracy Theorist2 Gaslight, Gatekeep, Girlboss23 Clap Clap Clap Award35 Drama Therapist Award2 Award Hoarder Enabler12 Wholesome Troll7 Emotional Support Viewer2 Sassy Tomato4 Free Range Tomato5 Tomato of Chaos2 Thread Historian6 Boba Brainstormer9 Notification Ninja1 Lore Librarian2 Mic Drop Darling4 Emotional Bandage8 Reply Hugger23 Soulmate Screamer20 Big Brain Award36
Replying to Kate Mar 13, 2021
but the police investigation (as stated in the article) said it was the car with his plate number. Even assuming…
I don't have that good of a memory, I just rewatched the scene hahahha
0 0
Replying to Kate Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
but the police investigation (as stated in the article) said it was the car with his plate number. Even assuming…
Tian was shown to get to hospital in ambulance tho lol

Also, it's more of him organizing the car race not just suggesting it. Him and Tul planned how to "clear the road", where to race etc. So even if he did not take part in the race, he took part in organizing it. Also, Tul is partially responsible too. So IF you planned to rob a bank and had all prepared, but did not take part in the robbing itself, even legally speaking you would be partially responsible. Since the criminal activity would not happen without your involvement.
1 2
Replying to ABingeMuffin13 Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
I honestly see this going either of 2 ways1. Is that Tian aldready hasd the stroke at the time the accident happened…
the website said she died in the car race. So Tian would be driving his own car, and the other dude would be driving his own. The guy obviously did not "win" the car since Tian's parents were the ones that "sold" it after the accident.
0 1
Replying to ABingeMuffin13 Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
I honestly see this going either of 2 ways1. Is that Tian aldready hasd the stroke at the time the accident happened…
1. then who drove his car?
2. as you said, he got to the hospital in ambulance so it was not his friends who drove him there.
0 4
Replying to AnniaD Mar 12, 2021
How was his directing job bad? (I'm genuinely asking, I'm curious to read other opinions)
it does not match the directing and editing style of all the other episodes and scenes. That's why I am saying it's not cohesive.
0 0
Replying to Kate Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
but the police investigation (as stated in the article) said it was the car with his plate number. Even assuming…
he did not. Tul literally told him before he got into the car that it's a bad idea, and Tian said he has to race coz the other dude will see him as coward otherwise.

If it was not him driving the car, who was? There was only Tul next to him right before the race. So what, Tul went for a race when Tian passed out and went to hospital?

Legally speaking him not taking part in the race makes him innocent. FOR ME morally speaking he is still partially responsible as he was the one to suggest the race in the first place. He was the one to put that illegal activity in motion.
1 4
Replying to AnniaD Mar 12, 2021
How was his directing job bad? (I'm genuinely asking, I'm curious to read other opinions)
well, still bad directing, as it does not match the style of all the other scenes. You can show the raw aspects of the scene while still being cohesive in style.
0 2
Replying to dllmzca Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
It this were to play out, it would be a major mistake for the writers to make. That would just blow up the narrative…
I am scared they will give some bullshit explanation how he was not involved and is blameless to give that happy Disney ending, where he main character can be nothing but good.
1 1
Replying to AnniaD Mar 12, 2021
How was his directing job bad? (I'm genuinely asking, I'm curious to read other opinions)
I'd still call it poor directing. Most dramas (this one not being expectation) have cohesive style of directing for all scenes. So switching is just this one for this one scene makes no sense. It took me out of the story a bit, coz it just did not flow well with the rest of the episode.
2 1
Replying to JohnGotti Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
Interesting theory! But, as I remember it (please correct me if I got it wrong), Tian was in the hospital at the…
Pretty sure the badminton scene was how he got diagnosed with the heart problem and they said he needs the surgery. While the transplant surgery happened right after the race. When they get him to surgery room he is wearing the same shirt he was wearing in the casino and before the car race.
3 1
Replying to AnniaD Mar 12, 2021
How was his directing job bad? (I'm genuinely asking, I'm curious to read other opinions)
It felt like a one take self made video. Mostly just still camera with angles changed just few times. At times it was also extremely shaky. There was not focus on any detail. When they were kissing, the camera was literally in their faces, way too close, it made me feel like I'm watching home made soft-porn.

It just felt like there was not much thought put into planning what and how they want to present. What should be the focus of the shot, what it should represent.

At the end, the acting was good, but the directing did not compliment it at all. Compare it even to the lunch scene. How the camera cut from Shu Yi to Shi De. How we saw the build up of emotions with the shots of Shi De typing faster and stronger as he can't focus and control his emotions. None of these details and plan of directing was seen in the sofa scene. It was like: you do the acting and we will just stand and film it from like 3 different angles and try to edit it later.
5 8
On A Tale of Thousand Stars Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
I know a lot of people feel bad for Tian, and I get that since we mostly observed him as his "new self" that is caring, loving and selfless. But whenever it was his car or the other dude's he was racing with car that hit Torfun, Tian is still at least partially responsible for her death, since it was his idea to race in the first place. At least partially, because of his irresponsible behavior in the past a good person died.

Unless they will tell us in the future episodes that Tian had literally nothing to do with the accident and the car race was not the reason she died. But that's just bad writing, so I hope it's not going this way lol
3 12
Replying to Maybe123 Mar 12, 2021
Title A Tale of Thousand Stars Spoiler
I don´t think that Tian killed the teacher, i think that it was the one he was racing with and he doesnt remember…
but the police investigation (as stated in the article) said it was the car with his plate number.
Even assuming it was not his car, he is still partially responsible, since he was the one to even suggest the car race in the first place. So it's not like he is blameless here.
1 10
Replying to amber a kimseonholic Mar 10, 2021
Well i'm liking first 3 eps a lot so i guess i'll survive and enjoy this a lot lol as always great review!!
yeah I struggled a bit at first hahahaha
but it got sooo much better later on :D
1 0
On Beyond Evil Mar 9, 2021
Title Beyond Evil Spoiler
Who is the killer? God fucking knows.
What I know is the fact the police apparently did not take statement from Jin Mook after his daughter was kidnapped and her fingers were found. If this is not the most ridiculous and shitty police work, I don't know what is.
3 1
Replying to Sunset Mar 5, 2021
Title Mouse
This one had a more exciting 1st episode than BE.. that one bored me until the last 10 minutes with that man's…
Well.. for each their own. It took me 2 hours to finish first episode of Mouse with the amount of incorrect and dumb ideas presented in it, while I was glued to screen while watching BE.
Mouse is more plot driven, BE is character driven. I myself prefer slow burn character driven shows.
4 6
Replying to jpny01 Mar 4, 2021
Title Lovely Writer Spoiler
I think it worked well how it was done. It's not supposed to be romantic, it's supposed to scare you. The voiceover…
it does sounds like Kao's voice at the end. I checked few times. Maybe I am tripping now too hahaha
0 0
Replying to 5480719 Mar 4, 2021
Title I Can See Your MBTI Spoiler
MBTI was derived from Carl Jung's theory of Cognitive Functions. In his theory, we have four main functions: the…
The test was NOT initially created based on whatever dominant functions you are talking about. I'm questioning validity of the test. you cannot half way through change and re-do the theory to the point it's not recognizable.

Most articles that "support" Myers–Briggs were written and published in association with Myers-Briggs Foundation and independent studies were extremely critical about it. As a scientific method it's close to zodiac signs. The authors had NO training in understanding psychological theories or how psychological tools should be created. They had less than basic understanding of psychology as a study field.

They completely ignored THE MOST IMPORTANT step in creating any theory or test based on that theory: validation and research. They made a theory without checking if it express in reality - guess what, it doesn't. That's why Myers–Briggs is not taken seriously in scientific community. Coz it fails all scientific criteria to be taken serious.
0 1
Replying to jpny01 Mar 4, 2021
Title Lovely Writer Spoiler
I think it worked well how it was done. It's not supposed to be romantic, it's supposed to scare you. The voiceover…
ohhhhh..... I totally missed the switch in narration (this is what happens when you watch an episode in the middle of the night with low volume audio hahaha).
Well then, scrap my idea hahaha
0 2