Details
- Last Online: 3 hours ago
- Gender: Female
- Location: Manyang Police Substation
- Contribution Points: 834 LV6
- Birthday: February 24
- Roles:
- Join Date: December 15, 2017
- Awards Received:
57 
165 
9 
1 
4 
3 
1 
1 
2 
1 
1 
2 
5 
3 
1 
1 
2 
2 
3 
9
Otherwise, it will stay as is. You can submit an edit (edit this page -> content rating) about the change of the content rating as long as you have a valid source.
JCW is a great actor generally, so I have no doubt he will be good in this even though I haven't watched it yet.
That wasn't logical to begin with. Their whole ''falling in love'' situation was pretty ridiculous and made zero sense, so I completely understand why you were left with that feeling.
Yes we will see.
For sure!
I mean, it was never allowed but that does not mean it is not happening. Plus let's not forget this is not Seoul, it is a small town/village where everyone knows everyone. That is exactly what is happening in small places and whoever did something wrong gets punished and ostracized. Some years ago a kid in my village stole something from a market. Everyone avoided him, stopped selling him stuff. He was young and you know what happened? He killed himself. It is unfair and sad but that is the cruel reality of small town places. If you are branded a killer, everyone treats you as one. He may not be the real murderer, but he was convicted as such and everyone considers him one.
Again, I don't think it was about thinking he is a criminal or not. ML is branded as a criminal and he blames himself for his wife's murder -and the fact that he probably couldn't do anything about it- so he takes out his anger on the ML. He treats him like he is the one that killed his wife, cause that is how he copes. It is wrong undoubtedly but that is what happens.
It is not weird that he is not listening to him yet -completely at least, cause he knows something is wrong with that case-. Let's not forget that for the viewers the ML is innocent, but for everyone in that place the ML found the body of the woman he was convicted of murdering and no one could find all these years. They can all think he just wanted her to be found finally and he knew from the get-go where she was -even if that fundamentally makes no sense-.
I agree that he is staying cause he wants to find out the truth and he accepts all beatings because he feels guilty. That aside, even though the ML doesn't remember and is saying he didn't do it, I feel that back then he was semi-convinced he did it. He was beaten, didn't eat and was mistreated for who knows how long and he was basically a kid. People he trusted told him to accept that he did it and at some point I believe he truly thought he did.
It is unfair, but it is not unrealistic. Many times the police is trying to close cases by making someone a scape-goat. Plus, this time it seems that many people are involved, so it is even more possible the whole investigation was rigged because powerful and important people -even from inside the police- were part of the crime.
He did check I think. I am not sure if it is shown and if he even can check all details since the investigation is closed, but at some point he mentions some details of the murder to the main lead. He also asked the chief police man and other police officers about the case. He is doubting. It is not his job to investigate a closed case, but he is doubting and I think that soon enough he will be searching more thoroughly -even illegally, if they don't legally reopen the case-.
For me the detective is a pretty well written character so far. He may be unlikable but comparing to everyone else there, he is the only one that has definitely not committed the crime and the only one questioning what happened back then.
He shouldn't be a police officer, yes! 100%. He is violent, he uses his fists. He is the type of ''shoot first, asks questions later'', but he is still the only one that is thinking and doubting about that case. He was the one telling to the rest of the police force to keep investigating the overpass case, even though it was legally closed. Plus, there was a huge possibility the chief officer knew what happened and covered it up. That man that saw what happened was in his place and then the case closed. Everyone is blaming the ML to a point that they don't care investigating about his mom's case. The cop is prejudiced against him not so much cause he got convicted, but because he wants someone to use as a punch bag after what happened to his wife.
The young girl is in my opinion the usual plot tool character so far. Yes, she wasn't hostile against him just suspicious. But who on their right mind leads a convicted criminal -and a murderer at that- to a place where a dead body could be? And not only that, she has 0 sense of danger.
We as viewers see every reaction of the ML every part of his story. We know it was not him. We know something sus happened back then. BUT she only met him like two times and only knows that he is a convicted killer and yet she chooses to take him in the middle of the night in the middle of nowhere, when she is completely alone to find a possible dead body. Don't get me started on the stupid phone commercial where she had to take a pic of those remains, like she couldn't hear the ML crying his eyes-out screaming Bo Yeong's name.
I think were we lost it is the cop. I agree completely he is not a good detective in terms of morals and being a professional. He is flawed and deeply problematic. I mean he basically made Bo Yeong's father admit what happened by feeding him alcohol and cigarettes lol.
He is not a good cop but who is in that town? He is the only one in the police force that is doubting what happened back then and he is asking questions about it, even though the case closed more than 10 years ago.
P.S. That got way too long, my apologies
To each his own. I am more worried by the fact that the original source is less than 400 pages, and the eps are way too long and many, so I feel like they have added many unecessary things and that is why the pacing doesn't work for me. On the other hand, it is not too bad either.
1. It was revealed -as expected- that he was abusive. I don't think he killed her though. The only possibility for me right now is that he may have assaulted her before her death and that is why she was crying. But because he was physically abusive it doesn't necessarily mean he was also a r@pist.
2. I agree. I think she had something to do with Da Eun's death. I suspect Da Eun was having an inappropriate relationship with that doctor. She may have found out and killed her or something -since she was the gf of the ML-
I think she is way too obsessed with the ML to be completely innocent. It seems like a person that would do anything to succeed. Plus, what got me even more interested is that one of the people in Su Oh's painting was wearing glasses and she did as a student. I am not 100% sure she is evil, but she is definitely unstable.
Well it is based on a book -even though I am not sure how close to it the show is- And honestly it is not really that unrealistic unfortunately. There are quite a few cases where the cops beat people and force them to confess and many rigged trials.
I think the friends r@ped Bo Yeong and the uncle probably covered the crime since his son was probably there tooo.
I completely agree and I hope we see them cooperate to find out the truth in the next eps
He was probably involved in the assault along with that nurse friend.
- The cop friend (along with the nurse guy) had probably something to do with Bo Yeong's death or at least her assault.
1. The cop friend was awkward when it was revealed that Bo Yeong's underwear was missing
2. The cop friend starting shouting at the ML when he talked about Bo Yeong to the cop and when he mentioned that breacelet that fell off her hand
3. The nurse friend was also suspicious
=> If they are involved it explains why they are playing the good friends and why they never visited him in prison -> They are feeling guilty and scared for what they did (or saw)
- The painting
1. Su Oh's painting revealed four people in the murder scene (could even be 5 if someone was driving that truck thing)
2. Three of them were on the one side of the painting and one on the other ->
- Maybe Su Oh was that ''one'' person and he was there more as an observer and not as the cultprit.
- That ''one'' person could be an adult (honestly the way he was painted reminded me of Su Oh's dad) -> That means he was involved somehow probably covering up the crime
- The nurse friend and cop friend were probably two of the people in the painting something that proves that nurse friend lied when he said to the main lead that they wouldn't go to that warehouse without him
- I think the most interesting part of the painting is that one of those three people was wearing glasses. And there are only two people wearing glasses if I remember correctly -> One is that politicians husband (less likely) and the other is Na Geyon
=> Na Gyeon is obsessed with the ML even though it seems that she wasn't really part of their friend group. She was more of an observer. She admitted that she built her whole life in a way that would attract his attention. She could easily be the killer or she was involved/knows something, especially since Da Eun was ML's girlfriend (or at least the girl he liked).
- End of episode four Bo Yeong's mom said they killed her with that uncle
Obviously it was probably metaphorical. It is most probable that they had an affair and Bo Yeong found out.
- Why was Bo Yeong crying?
1. It could be because of the affair
2. It could be that she was already raped by someone before her death
+ Her father was confirmed to be beating her -unless it wasn't him that did it and she covered the real one my mentioning her dad (I doubt it though, cause she would probably come up with a different excuse)- I don't think he would rape her, but it is not really impossible.
- That doctor (politician's husband)
1. Dude was already suspicious when he mentioned that assault center for women that he built...
2. It is obvious he is having inappropriate relationships with his patients
3. I think it is more likely for him to be the one killing Da Eun
- He may have been the one the grandma heard on her phone
- She may have been his patient and they ended having an inappropriate relationship (she may have threatened him of revealing their relationship)
4. The doctor seems to be scared of his wife. She either knows or she helped taking care of the situation back then.
=> I hope the cop and the ML start investigating together so this could get more interesting. Honestly, it is a bit more slow paced than I would like so far and I am wondering what the revelations will be, since for the time being I have quite a few -as you can tell- theories in my mind that could be true. I am wondering if there will be a twist.
But, yeah I generally agree, especially about that dude that forced him to plead guilty all those years ago along with his ''uncle''.
I think Su Oh may have been there. In the painting he drew there were four people and one of them was standing seperately from the others. It could be him being there as an observer. Father definitely has something to do with it.