News 
This review may contain spoilers
good story poorly executed
i think its a good story slightly poorly executed as if first few episodes did not know how the story would build the friend who is introduced makes absolutely no sense he does not question who is the duplicate of the two . the friends meetup when they looked the same how did the rat know who real moon jae was the officer that is . Noja had no role what so ever! he was only used by rat to probably kill moon jae when at the same time he did not wanted him to actually kill. Noja end up backing moon jae for what , money? no backstory for noja with the rat not much still gets tangled .i do not write reviews but this story was so badly executed i had to.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
Nv Ban Nan Zhuang Wo Bai Wan Le Shan Hun Zong Cai
0 people found this review helpful
? HIS WIFE, HIS MALE ASSISTANT—AND HIS COMPLETE IDENTITY CRISIS
OVERALL IMPRESSION🌟This familiar unknown-spouse storyline received a wonderfully fresh twist through cross-dressing, workplace romance and an ML who became convinced he was falling for another man. The escalating misunderstandings were ridiculous in the best possible way, while Shu Tong and Zhong Xi’s natural chemistry made the romance surprisingly convincing.
WHAT I LIKED💖
• Zhong Xi’s disguise was among the most convincing I have seen in a short drama. She changed her mannerisms, behaviour and overall presence rather than merely putting on a suit. She was beautiful as the FL and genuinely handsome as An Qi Ming!
• I loved that the FL was technically competing with herself for her husband’s affection. Every jealous misunderstanding became funnier because the ML had no idea that his wife and irresistible assistant were the same person.
• Shu Tong was excellent as the sharp-tongued, possessive and increasingly bewildered ML. His attempts to explain away his attraction as professional concern were priceless.
• The central irony was perfect: the ML wanted to divorce the wife he barely knew because they lacked an emotional connection, yet unknowingly fell for her once he finally spent meaningful time with her.
• The leads’ chemistry developed naturally through working together, teasing and growing mutual respect. Their relationship felt playful without becoming childish.
• I appreciated the drama’s handling of consent. When either lead was drugged, the sober person refused to take advantage, avoiding one of C-short land’s most unpleasant clichés.
• The ML did not blindly accept the scheming woman’s claims and was capable of answering back instead of allowing her to manipulate every situation.
• The FL’s brother and the ML’s childhood friend added their own amusing chemistry and strengthened the comedy without overshadowing the leads.
WHAT I DISLIKED⚠️
• The misunderstanding occupied a considerable portion of the drama. I found it entertaining, although viewers who dislike prolonged secret identities may become impatient.
• I would have preferred more kissing and romantic scenes once the leads’ feelings became clear. Their chemistry was strong enough to support considerably more romance.
• Although the disguise was unusually successful, certain physical details still required the usual suspension of disbelief.
PRODUCTION AND PERFORMANCES🎭
• Shu Tong once again demonstrated why he is such a versatile and experienced actor. Whether portraying a scumbag, romantic lead or confused husband questioning everything he knew about himself, his performance remained smooth and natural.
• Zhong Xi’s expressive comedy carried much of the drama. Her timing, charisma and ability to create two distinct identities made the familiar script feel new.
• The direction and supporting performances elevated an old premise through clever comic situations, lively pacing and well-handled emotional turns.
FINAL THOUGHTS💭
This was a pleasant, clean and hilarious romantic comedy with no abusive ML and no exhausting revenge plot overwhelming the relationship. The twists, misunderstandings and identity confusion produced plenty of laughter, while the leads’ effortless chemistry gave the story genuine sweetness. Shu Tong and Zhong Xi remain a classic pairing, and their performances transformed a familiar trope into something memorable. Highly recommended—and I would happily watch it again!
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
Unfiltered Rant: A Mess of Missed Potential
Oh God. SPRING OF THE BLADE, WHAT HAPPENED TO YOU???If you’ve been watching C-dramas long enough, you probably already know both leads. And yes, I’m a big Xu Kai fan, so how could I not be excited for this? I mean, Yan Rui is HOT. The smugness, the arrogance, that “I can do whatever I want and somehow get away with it” attitude, and plus those deep brown eyes... honestly, he was the eye candy carrying me through this dark drama. And despite all that, what I thought was going to be a great drama turned into a massive disappointment. I genuinely thought this was going to be one of those dark, revenge-driven dramas that completely pulled me in. Instead, the further I got into it, the more everything started falling apart. You can absolutely blame my expectations for this one because the premise had so much potential.
For starters, why was this drama filmed in such ridiculously dark lighting? The lighting is gloomy almost throughout the entire drama. I understand wanting a dark and mysterious atmosphere, but you don't need to make every scene look like it’s happening at midnight. Then there’s the Xie family, who are rotten to the core. They're rotten to the core, but the drama never gives enough convincing motivation behind their actions. Watching everything they did was enough to raise my blood pressure because they were basically awful just for the sake of being awful.
And my biggest rant has to be the whole plot twist surrounding Madam Xie, the father’s identity, and the Xie family secret. The drama tries to turn her regret over the past into this huge emotional revelation, especially when she claims that she’s trying to atone for her sins by protecting Xie Qing Yuan, something she failed to do for her own daughter. BUT HELLO??? You were also the woman who stood by and supported the father’s decision to send the female lead, a physically vulnerable woman, into the middle of a riot filled with rebels, all in the name of protecting the Xie family. You watched your own family mistreat your only blood relative, for fuck’s sake! And now we’re supposed to accept this sudden wave of guilt and redemption? The whole thing completely contradicts her previous actions.
And then we get to the biggest problem: the plot itself. The plot completely loses the plot.
The premise was genuinely interesting at the beginning, but somewhere around the middle, the story started losing direction. By the final stretch, it felt like the writers were rushing to tie together ten different storylines at once. There were so many plot holes and convenient decisions that I eventually stopped trying to make sense of them. Xie Qing Yuan's storyline actually made sense to me. I understood her motivations and why she was willing to go after the Xie family the way she did. Yan Rui, however? What exactly are we doing here? 😭
One of the most ridiculous things to me was how Yan Rui could just walk into the female lead's internal family meetings whenever he wanted, and somehow nobody could do anything about it simply because he was an official. Aren't family affairs supposed to be private? The fact that everyone just seemed to accept his presence made no sense to me. This man supposedly came back to uncover the truth about his family and take down corruption, yet so much of his storyline revolved around showing up whenever the female lead was in trouble. And honestly, I started questioning whether his constant intervention was even helping her. Everyone could clearly see that he was backing her, so wouldn't that just make her position even more vulnerable?
If the writer intended Yan Rui's constant rescuing and unwavering support for Xie Qing Yuan to come across as romantic simp behavior, then they completely missed the mark. His actions actually made the whole “Xie Qing Yuan is my blade” premise feel pointless. Xie Qing Yuan was introduced as a smart and cunning woman who knew how to navigate the dangerous dynamics within her own family. Yet Yan Rui kept stepping in whenever she was in trouble, even to the point of openly backing her during family matters where his presence made little sense. At some point, it stopped feeling like romantic devotion and started undermining the female lead's own capabilities. That disconnect really bothered me because it weakened both characters. Xie Qing Yuan became less capable than she was initially portrayed, while Yan Rui's motivations became increasingly muddled.
And Zhou Ye... God damn it. 😭 I was actually looking forward to seeing her in a darker revenge role, but I could constantly feel that she was acting. Her expressions often felt stiff and awkward, especially during scenes that were supposed to carry a lot of emotional weight. Whether her character was devastated, furious, or calculating, I struggled to feel the emotion behind her performance or connect with her character. Honestly, I don't know what went wrong here. The cast was promising, the premise was promising, and the potential was definitely there. But the writing, editing, character motivations, and rushed plot completely lost me. Xu Kai face was doing a lot of heavy lifting, because without him I don't know if I would've finished this.
Was this review helpful to you?
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Blade Without an Edge
Spring of the Blade follows Xie Qing Yuan and Shen Run, who both survived a family tragedy. The two children promised to live and avenge what happened to their families. After being separated, they reunite years later. Their relationship then develops from childhood friendship into partnership and eventually love. This is usually the kind of setup that should work for me: personal trauma, long-brewing revenge, hidden identities, political intrigue, family conflict, and a romance built on mutual trust. The ingredients were all there. The problem is that the drama never quite knew how to cook them.The opening narration from Qing Yuan was actually one of the things I liked. Having her tell the story from her own perspective immediately made the revenge feel personal, and the beginning was relatively neat and focused. I expected the following episodes to gradually peel back the past and show us enough of their suffering to understand where their anger came from. Instead, the drama kept most of the important emotional material at arm’s length. We knew that Qing Yuan’s mother had been killed and that Shen Run’s entire family had been massacred, but the flashbacks rarely gave those tragedies enough emotional weight. They provided information, but not enough emotional ammunition. I wanted rage. I wanted grief. I wanted the kind of flashbacks that make you sit there thinking, “Okay, burn the whole place down.” Instead, I mostly sat there thinking, “That sounds terrible.” There is a significant difference between understanding why a character wants revenge and actually feeling their need for revenge alongside them.
This becomes even more noticeable because revenge is supposed to be the backbone of the story. The premise suggests that they are not simply trying to punish the people responsible for their family's tragedy, but also wants to clear their family's name. That is a perfectly reasonable reason for the initial investigation to take priority over revenge. The problem is that the investigation stretches on for so long that it overshadows the revenge. For a revenge-driven character, Qing Yuan does surprisingly little deliberate scheming. Her main calculated move is entering the Xie household. After that, we mostly watch her live her life as a Xie, investigate the past, and take advantage of family conflicts whenever the opportunity arises. She is often fueling fires rather than deliberately building the bonfire. Similarly, Shen Run's revenge feels underdeveloped. For a revenge drama, the revenge itself felt strangely passive.
The drama also leans heavily on foreshadowing and mutual understanding between the leads. The actors have mentioned in interviews that the story deliberately uses this structure, showing something first and explaining it later, while also having Qing Yuan and Shen Run make decisions based on the assumption that the other person will understand what they are doing. In theory, this can create suspense and make two intelligent characters feel like they are several moves ahead. The problem is that the drama does not give us enough character development or backstory to make those assumptions feel earned. We are repeatedly told, in effect, “They understand each other,” without being given enough material to understand why they understand each other so well. Their mutual trust works much better in the romance than it does in the revenge plot because the romantic chemistry is actually visible on screen. Outside of that, the writing often asks the audience to fill in too many blanks.
The penny token is probably the clearest example of the drama setting up something that made me expect more than it ultimately delivered. There was an ongoing discussion about whether Shen Run already knew that Qing Yuan was his childhood friend. I was one of the minorities who thought he did not know, partly because I assumed the penny token would eventually become important. It was given to us, highlighted, mentioned in the synopsis, and connected to their childhood. Surely this thing was going somewhere. Nope. Shen Run already knew who Qing Yuan was from the beginning, although the drama never properly explains exactly how he figured it out. Many explanations could work, but the drama never commits to one. More importantly, none of them require the penny token. Qing Yuan does not use it to identify Shen Run either. The eventual revelation simply confirms what she already suspects. So what exactly was the token doing there? It is one of those details that made me realize the drama had ideas, but not always a clear idea of what to do with them.
Qing Yuan herself was another case of lost potential. She was introduced as intelligent, determined, resilient, courageous, and capable of scheming. Unfortunately, as the story progressed, she was increasingly reduced to a damsel in distress. She would put herself in dangerous situations, apparently betting that Shen Run would come to save her, and he would. Once or twice, this can be cute. Repeatedly doing it weakens the character. I also have mixed feelings about Zhou Ye’s performance. I think she has roles that suit her very well and others that still feel like a work in progress, and Qing Yuan unfortunately falls into the latter category for me. At first, I enjoyed her colder and more intimidating expressions. The longer I watched, however, the more those expressions started feeling fake and performative. Some viewers describe her performance as bland or emotionless, while others defend the lack of expression as appropriate for a character who has suppressed her emotions for years. Ironically, I think her lack of expression sometimes feels too expressive. Instead of becoming one with the character, it occasionally feels like she is role-playing revenge in her own head. There are moments when Qing Yuan comes across less like a woman consumed by years of grief and more like a salty girl sulking at her family while imagining herself in a revenge drama. That sounds harsher than I intend, but that was genuinely how some scenes landed for me.
The comparison that came to mind was Zhuang Han Yan from The Glory. Both characters have a certain emotional restraint and carry themselves as women who are carefully calculating their next moves. The difference is that Han Yan’s restraint felt natural and impactful to me, whereas Qing Yuan’s often felt performed. That said, Zhou Ye has moments where she absolutely gets Qing Yuan right. Her snarky expressions during family drama were probably my favorite. They felt a little modern for the setting, but they also made me feel what she was feeling. I could practically hear the internal “Are you people serious?” I also cannot completely put the blame on Zhou Ye because directing plays a major role here. The attack scenes during the bandit infiltration in particular made Qing Yuan look strangely helpless. I even ended up watching BTS footage because I was curious about how those scenes were directed, and it became clearer why the character had so little to do. The staging often prioritizes men coming in to save her rather than allowing Qing Yuan to demonstrate any survival instinct.
Xu Kai, on the other hand, landed Shen Run for me. His character is introduced through the identity of Yan Rui, before eventually revealing himself as Shen Run. What impressed me most was how consistently Xu Kai maintained the distinction between the two personas. Yan Rui is corrupt, sly, mischievous, flirty, and irritating in exactly the right way, while Shen Run carries himself with a much more commanding, righteous, and reliable presence. Even his speech patterns and expressions change appropriately. I especially loved how the drama managed to change our perception of him through Qing Yuan’s eyes. There is a scene where Shen Run walks ahead of Qing Yuan and she watches his back in slow motion. Suddenly, that same back that previously belonged to an annoying and mischievous Yan Rui looks charismatic and dependable. It is a simple visual trick, but it works beautifully.
And honestly, the biggest reason I stayed with this drama for as long as I did was the chemistry between Zhou Ye and Xu Kai. Together, they are electric. Their early dynamic as Qing Yuan and Yan Rui is filled with flirtatious banter, coded conversations, metaphors, close proximity, and that constant feeling that neither person is saying exactly what they mean. They reminded me of Elizabeth Bennet and Mr. Darcy from Pride and Prejudice. There is a delicious push and pull between them. Yan Rui keeps trying to partner with Qing Yuan while she keeps her guard up, yet she repeatedly finds herself relying on him anyway. The robe tug, the almost-touching moments, the nose-to-nose proximity, the eye contact, and the dialogue all create a tension that the plot itself sometimes fails to maintain. When the line between Yan Rui and Shen Run becomes clearer, their relationship changes naturally as well. The proposal and wedding scenes were particularly satisfying, and the earlier flirtation had enough heat to carry several episodes by itself. Unfortunately, the romance also suffers from the drama’s structural problems. After the couple reaches its emotional peak, the story simply moves on. Instead of continuing to show them working together as partners, the drama shifts its attention toward bringing down the villains.
The supporting characters also suffered from writing that did not match the performances. Li Chong Xin is probably the biggest example. I still don't know when he fell in love with Qing Yuan or what exactly she did to leave such a lasting impression on him. The drama gives us their encounter, but it does not convincingly show the moment he becomes fascinated by her. His pursuit therefore feels less like a natural development and more like a plot device designed to establish Qing Yuan as highly desirable and give Shen Run a reason to be jealous. Xie Shu is another missed opportunity. The actor gives a convincing performance, but the character writing becomes increasingly exaggerated and dramatic. He is introduced as a formidable villain, yet by the end he feels strangely beatable and even pathetic. I can understand why some viewers enjoyed the actor’s crazier performance, but for me it was too much. The problem is not that Xie Shu is dramatic. The problem is that the writing does not adequately connect the character we saw earlier with the man we see at the end.
Visually, Spring of the Blade initially lived up to the trailer’s promise. I particularly liked how the visual style changed with the mood of the scenes. The drama also did not shy away from showing violence, which I appreciated. Unfortunately, the visual quality also became increasingly repetitive. The greenish, yellowish, and purplish color grading started appearing so frequently during daytime scenes that it became more noticeable than the actual cinematography. The nighttime scenes grew darker as well, and the production increasingly relied on the Xie family hall as the main setting. I understand the budget limitations, and nothing about the sets completely pulled me out of the story, but the production eventually felt increasingly confined and familiar. The funny part is that this did give me more opportunity to focus on the dialogue and script. I am not entirely sure that was an advantage.
The music was another issue. I really liked the opening instrumental theme because it immediately established an eerie and suspenseful atmosphere. Unfortunately, that is probably the only piece of music from the drama that stayed with me positively. The volume and placement of the songs were frequently distracting, especially during dialogue-heavy scenes. There were moments when the music seemed to compete with the actors instead of supporting them. Since this is a drama that relies heavily on dialogue, monologues, clues, and information, missing even a few words can make a scene confusing.
Then came the final five to six episodes, and this is where it completely lost me. The ending is incredibly convenient, and the twist involving Qing Yuan’s mother feels like one of the drama’s biggest missed opportunities. There was potential for something genuinely shocking, but the execution made it feel underwhelming. The Emperor’s decisions were especially convenient. I understand the argument that no one outside the Emperor can truly know what he thinks, but the way this story uses him makes him feel less like a powerful ruler and more like a plot mechanism that says yes whenever Shen Run needs something. It is one thing for a trusted official or powerful minister to have influence over an Emperor. It is another thing for the Emperor to repeatedly hand over convenient solutions to a lone wolf like Shen Run with barely any resistance.
Commissioner Hu suffers from the same problem. For most of the story, he is presented as a mysterious and powerful figure who controls numerous influential people in Hengtang. His supposedly formidable attack is then stopped before it even gets started, largely because of Chong Xin’s arrival. Shen Run later takes him down with the Emperor’s authority. I genuinely had to wonder why the drama spent so much time building him up if he could be dealt with that easily. If the villain can be defeated by the narrative equivalent of pressing the “Emperor’s Will” button, then perhaps we did not need all those episodes of planning to defeat him.
Xie Shu’s downfall is even more absurd. He goes from being a supposedly manipulative and dangerous villain to someone who seems to have lost all sense of reality. His final antics are so exaggerated that I found myself laughing instead of feeling the satisfaction of revenge. The idea that years of manipulation and moral corruption could eventually push someone toward madness is perfectly reasonable, but the drama does not properly build that psychological progression. Instead, Xie Shu suddenly becomes incredibly theatrical, then turns around and speaks perfectly rationally when the plot requires it. And once again, the Emperor’s convenient will does much of the heavy lifting. Qing Yuan and Shen Run do not get the elaborate revenge plan that I had been waiting for. There is no grand chess game where they finally outsmart Xie Shu. Things simply fall conveniently into place. Even the final scene where Qing Yuan and Shen Run approach him while holding the fire igniter together was so dramatically staged that I laughed.
The character endings were similarly rushed. I did not mind Xie Qing He and Pei Guan Ling's brief happy ending since they were always more peripheral. Xie Qing Rong’s ending was ambiguous and bittersweet. Xie Qing Ru's ending with Chong Xin was strange because the drama does not spend enough time exploring the complicated implications of him accepting a woman whose family is responsible for his father’s downfall. As for Qing Yuan and Shen Run, the drama barely gives them the romantic closure they deserve. Their fishing village scene is sweet, but it is also brief and vague. I wanted more. I wanted to see them actually live after everything they had survived. I wanted the story to breathe for a moment and show us what their happily ever after looked like.
Ultimately, Spring of the Blade is a drama that had all the right ingredients but could not consistently put them together. Despite all of that, I did enjoy the drama, especially up to around episode 24. The romance was difficult to ignore. I just wish the story had trusted its own premise as much as I trusted the trailer. Spring of the Blade could have been a sharp revenge drama with a compelling romance woven through it. Instead, it became a compelling romance trapped inside a revenge drama that gradually forgot what it wanted to be.
Was this review helpful to you?
A good female soldier.
Honestly when i saw the 7.4/10 on MDL for this drama i trought it's was a bad one BUT since i watched Legend of The Female General i'have a hard time to found some drama with a female soldier, so i tried this one.And honestly it's a good surprise, the story of the FL take a couple of episodes to start but the whole army part is very well written, you dont have a barbie girl, with a perfect makeup everytime. You have a true female soldier, with scars, dust, powerfull mindset, a little bit of romance of course but she fight with her army brothers in the way its sound "realistic".
The global plot is a bit a mess, especially the last couple of episodes with very too much things happens. The ending is very good.
So if you are like me, tired of the lambda FL and you search a warrior one, give it a try, this drama is not bad.
Was this review helpful to you?
A soap opera-like drama
If you enjoy dramas that are dramatic for no reason, where everything is all over the place, with a smart vengeful female lead and a ruthless male lead, check this out!Zhou Ye and Xu Kai was a pairing I did not know I needed but enjoyed so bad. They had great chemistry and their acting was on point. Especially Xu Kai who embodied being a cutthroat lord yet a loser in love perfectly, his expressions were so great. And the supporting cast did a good job too. Some characters were annoying like no other to the point you'll want to slap them, while some others were so brazenly evil, you'll become enraged whenever you see their faces, lol. Get ready to have your blood pressure rising because of one specific family nonsense. XD
There is a lot of plot holes, the storyline is not well structured unfortunately and we have a rushed ending but the drama remains enjoyable because somehow it keeps you hooked. Secrets and crazy plot twists unravel in a way no one could have guess, it makes the show more thrilling, hehehe. The revenge is quite satisfying, no one is let off the hook. ^^
Overall, it's an averagely good watch, mainly because the actors play well despite the so-so production.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
A Perfectly Matched Viewing
I honestly didn't expect to enjoy a series I found out about through Reddit, but I suppose there's a first time for everything. It's been a while since I've truly enjoyed nearly every single episode of a series and Perfect Match was the one that brought me out of a rut! Plus, this show was HILARIOUS. There were so many parts throughout (outside of the obvious heartbreak and hardships) where I CACKLED. Like actually CACKLED out loud at the antics. It was so much fun.PLOT:
The main theme of the show surrounds Madam Li and her 6 daughters (5 real daughters, 1 adopted). The story develops around the seven characters, where Madam Li (widowed) and 5 of her daughters are moving to Bianjing, where Fuhui (daughter #2) lives with her family. The show displays the hardship of the Li family, of having to endure the humiliation of the Li men from other branches of the family extort and extract as much money from Madam Li. And this is where the story begins with a new life in Bianjing. They encounter hardships and heartbreak along the way.
The plot revolves around the family and really emphasizes the closeness of the sisters and the mother (which I absolutely loved). There isn't much backstabbing among the sisters; they all get along really well (even the 2 youngest have a semblance of understanding about the situation they're in) and how they all need to work together in order to succeed in life. This is the main theme of the series. It's very character-driven and shows how much each sister has the chance to grow as a person, even their mom does too (slightly) in the end.
Once the tea shop is established, the story follows each of the sisters and how they resolve the problems in their love lives. Although I usually roll my eyes at these plotlines, I truly enjoyed how this series was written (except for the last few episodes where I felt they rushed things for Qiongnu [adopted sister]). Other than that hump, the way they go into each of the sisters and their journey to falling in love was really sweet. A bit saccharine at times, but overall nice.
***SPOILER***
For Haode (sister #4) and Shen's storyline, I thought it was strange that they didn't really finish the whole subplot of his dad wanting to kill them? Maybe I missed something but I thought they were going to have some sort of reveal in the end but it focused more on Haode and Shen's relationship. Which is fine but why introduce that subplot if you weren't going to do anything about it in the end?
***END OF SPOILER***
CASTING:
I have adored Lu Yu Xiao ever since I saw her in My Journey to You and Wang Xing Yue is just too beautiful to look at ever since I discovered him in The Double (though I really TRULY wish someone would properly colour-match this handsome man! Like COME ON!! Why does he keep looking sallow in every shot?? I KNOW the makeup artists can do better). They were the first couple that fell in love and honestly, if they were dating IRL, I would be so happy! I felt their chemistry was soft and fun - obviously their characters called for it but they're so cute together.
I felt the cast did a really great job. My fave sisters were Kangning (sister #3) and Leshan (sister #5). Their cunning and Kangning's ability to spin tails was giving Sagittarius vibes, FOR SURE. This woman would be formidable in today's world. Leshan really stole my heart though. The youngest of the family, she's sheltered and pampered, and as a result of hanging with her sisters, even more cunning and ruthless when it comes to protecting them. It's funny to think about the youngest sister being the most ferocious but in way that's true (I'm the youngest). Plus, Leshan's ability to always have some sort of billy club on her when she marries into the Yang family was legendary. I CACKLED SO HARD WHEN SHE PULLED UP HER SKIRT TO REVEAL ANOTHER BILLY CLUB!!
I also have to give credit to Ni Hong Jie (Madam Li). She was the ferocious Mama Bear who goes out of her way to protect any of her kids, unless they deserved the trouble. Even though she had been widowed, browbeaten by her husband's family, she still managed to raise all of her children on her own, then when they were grown, brought them to a new city and opened a business that became successful. Plus, she was absolutely hilarious. Her expressions and her ferocity is matched by her ability to hit her children and protect her son-in-laws as well. I also loved the actress in Guardians of Dafeng though they really didn't use her artistic talent to its full potential.
OVERALL:
All in all, I enjoyed this show very much. I only gave it a 8.5/10 because there were a few plot holes but I understand that no story is ever perfect. The theme of community, of family, sisterhood, and never giving up is woven throughout the series really well. It does become a bit formulaic for each sister as the series goes on, but again, that's fine. It's not as noticeable as one might think.
If you're ever in the mood for a sweet romance that centers around women helping women, of outsmarting the men around you that they have to form an alliance to counteract your schemes, and hilarity, I would definitely recommend Perfect Match! It satisfied all of my C-drama cravings. The worst part is.... now I have to find a new show to watch! *cries in too many options*
Was this review helpful to you?
Before Ubukata Miku was an interesting writer...
Watched this drama written by Ubukata Miku because of how she had mixed genres in Until the T-Shirt Dries. I thought maybe it was her style, but this show, Where Does the Sea Begin, written before, was the exact opposite. It has one mood from beginning to end. Sadness, mellow repetitive music, supposedly heartbreaking child actress and more sadness.There is literally no point in watching 12 hours of the same thing, and I can't understand how she was able to write that.
Hopefully, her next works will be more in the vein of Until the T-Shirt Dries: great dialogues worthy of a play and directions that keep surprising the audience.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
spoilers (i think)
This is my third drama which I’ve watched after a year or two. I stopped watching c dramas cause I felt it had gotten so repetitive in its entirety after some bad watches and recently got back into it after watching prisoner of beauty and story of kunning palace. To be completely honest, pursuit of jade was not my first choice. This was straight after watching story of kunning palace (which I finished last Sunday) and as a bai Lu fan who binged only for love and till the end of the moon and believe it to be some of the greatest dramas ever, I was aiming to watch the first jasmine since it starred bai Lu and since I wasn’t too fond of zhang linghe’s role in SOKP, I genuinely felt this drama was to be overrated and had a negative bias towards it but after seeing for Tain xiewei reels I decided to give it a go, and boy did I give it a go.I started the drama 28th of sep, and after 3 days and 2 nights of straight binge watching, I can definitely say it lived up to its hype. To clarify I’ve never in my life binged something this hard and gotten so attached and addicted to a show as I did for this, the story was brilliant, characters were beyond amazing and the storyline/plot was also very good. Apologies if this is straight rambling, first review im writing for anything which ive watched and im just writing this fast and casually to distract myself while waiting for something
Now let’s get into the actual content of the drama. As most people have already mentioned, the xingu alley arc was probably the best parts of this drama and probably some of the best scenes and episodes of a drama I’ve ever seen. Changyu was introduced in a very funny and entertaining manner, which set up her character as this nice, stubborn, cute yet strong character. Xiewei’s portrayal of her character was truly fantastic, her facial expressions and the lines were incredibly funny which engrossed me into the drama even more. Zhang linghe in my opinion also redeem himself from SOKP, as he did manage to portray Xie Zheng in such a memorable fashion. From the initial conversations between changyu and Zheng where he spoke in a very tactful manner to his awkwardness towards a villager’s life and their daily food, he managed to capture the perfect version of a noble living in a village vibe. The chemistry between the two was also quite remarkable, at first glance they both had this contrast if lives and character. Zheng was a elegant, noble, well educated, injured/weak and reserved person whereas changyu was a more outspoken, straightforward, rough around the edges and while somewhat educated, more reliant on her strength to survive. As they begun to learn about one another, they slowly began to melt into a perfect match, where each filled the gaps that the other had and helped live a happy life. The gradual transition, particularly of Zheng’s relation with changyu was very memorable as he transitioned from being guarded, to feeling grateful, tofeeling respect, admiration, love and unrelenting devotion. It did not feel rushed or forced at all, and so naturally developed and felt very grounded to reality in a way.
The pacing itself was probably one of if not the best thing about the arc other than the main couple. Every episode felt so complete yet so integrated into the storyline. It didn’t feel like it was a sectioned story, each episode felt more like something that you would put in a memory book or like a diary. This was further amplified by the growing development of characters like the pig butchering squad that went from the village’s troublemakers to honest and loyal followers of changyu. The gradual exposure to outside events or characters also felt kind of natural, hinting at things without forcing it into the story. It was similar to the integration and removal of characters from the story. From the introduction of mrs zhao as a friendly neighbour to becoming a very attachable character who’s like a second mother to her, to the introduction and final exit of butcher guo that went from a salty competitor to someone who wants revenge towards them. Besides this, the application of side characters were also very good throughout the drama, the characters had very good screen time.
Now I believe this perfection lasted till about the linan massacre. Up until this point, the story progression seemed very elite, and I could agree if from the start till now were the whole first season if they had wanted to include more scenes or extend the story, and I feel this entire story should have been split into multiple seasons to truly make a perfect drama, but once yuanqing got saved by the bandit stronghold, everything felt somewhat forced and rushed. They could have definitely created some build up in the relationship between yaunqing and the stronghold master or a buildup to the actual bandit raid but the fact that it occurred so quickly felt rushed. I could even let it slide if they had expanded a bit more on the bandit raid and built it up more before ending the first season with changyu falling off the cliff but it was too rushed. Furthermore, the transition from being injured to escaping and looking for changning all the way to the bacia arc had a similar issue. There was no real explanation or illustration of changyu’s 2 month travel after the massacre and while I loved the character development of changyu, who now feels a lot more mature, there could have been so much potential which the story could’ve added into the arc. We could’ve gotten some more expansion into how she handled the losses or some sort of interaction between changyu with characters or something or like had a quick introduction or something of grand tutor Tao before their first interaction within the dam construction. Regarding the characters, story and other aspects of the arcs, still we’re very addictive and high quality. The only thing which degraded it would definitely be the pacing. The same thing could be said about the following arcs, like baxia could’ve definitely had potential for more plot points or expansions into it. The whole battle/arc felt way too underwhelming for the importance which it had. While the mount gu fort arc had much better pacing and stayed consistent with its characters, the vibe and the various chemistries, its main problem was still pace. We didn’t even get a proper introduction to how the princess popped up or the journey to the mount by changyu and the pig butchering squad, and some great action scenes for changyu. But it felt like the princess’s chemistry with advisor bungsun felt too forced, not to mention the potential for chemistry between the stronghold leader and yuanqing. Matter of fact, this was such a missed opportunity. We could’ve had such a great addition of rivalry or something sort of lore for the stronghold leader who’s trying to win over yaunqing or something but she literally faded into the background, and barely appeared for more than 15 minutes throughout the whole baxia arc. But back to my main point, this whole arc was very under developed, but I did like that it helped set up the stage for changyu to introduce herself as a peak warrior and further expanded and deepened Zheng and her relationship. In regards to the future storyline, it had similar themes of issues. Lord changxin’s death appeared way too underwhelming, the battle was over way too quickly and the fact that while it was a 30k plus army, the actual battle was dramatically underwhelming and just awkward in a way. This is similar to the other large scale combat scenes like the riot of linan, as there was no real portraying of 1000 elite units or the 10 thousand soldiers which the Shi brothers though the fort gu.
I regards to the end arc, it was very cinimetically well made. I loved the slow wrap up of the story with all the significant characters pulling up to the capital and the straightforwardness of changyu in face of the manipulating ministers, furthermore, it helped build up the significance of the finale and the slow destabalisation of the imperial court that ended with the coup. It also gave a pretty good ending for all the characters that remained, and I liked that closure which was brought from prime minister wei when talking to grand tutor tao as well as the revealment of the past throughout the episode as well as the heartfelt ending of them going back to xingu alley as they are greeted by the fallen residents as well as mr and mrs zhao. The main issue for this is once again the pacing. There was no real time for expansion into the capital arc, it felt too shallow and superficial and especially the end battle, it was so underwheliming considering it was the finale of the entire series. I truly feel like the capital arc had the potential to be pure peak, if it was appropriately paced so the ending while underwhelming was still a heartfelt ending that I enjoyed very much. The end credits of the what if was also such a nice touch, truly made me understand that my journey watching pursuit of jade was about to end.
if you have read this till the end, thanks and let me know if there are some unnecessary parts or something i should get rid of or aviod in writing future reviews.
Was this review helpful to you?
This Drama and My Overthinking Became Best Friends— Made Me Trust No One, Not Even Myself
I went into this drama thinking, “70 episodes? This better be worth it.”Somehow, I ended up wishing there were more.
And the funny thing is, I wasn't even watching Story of Yanxi Palace like a normal viewer. I was analyzing it. Every suspicious reaction, every strange decision, every little detail that didn't quite add up made my brain immediately go:
“Wait. That's suspicious.”
Then the investigation began.
I would form a theory, look for evidence, question my own theory, revise it when something didn't fit, and sometimes discover that I was completely wrong. Other times, I would get that incredibly satisfying feeling of realizing I had noticed something the drama wanted me to notice.
That was one of the biggest reasons I stayed hooked. I wasn't simply waiting to see what happened next—I was trying to figure out why it was happening.
Wei Yingluo was a huge reason I stayed invested. I loved her intelligence, initiative, critical thinking, and ability to turn problems into something she could solve. She doesn't simply wait for things to happen—she observes, thinks, adapts, and acts. I didn't agree with some methods she used, but that made her even more interesting to me.
I also became surprisingly attached to the characters. Some made me admire them, some frustrated me to no end, and some genuinely broke my heart. Even when I disagreed with someone's choices, I often found myself trying to understand what led them there.
What stayed with me most is how the drama constantly puts principles, loyalty, love, family, ambition, and survival against each other. Nobody gets through the palace simply by being clever or simply by being good. You have to understand people, understand the situation, and sometimes adapt without losing yourself.
And somehow, 70 episodes didn't feel like 70 episodes.
I laughed. I got angry. I became suspicious of practically everyone. I rooted for people, questioned people, and occasionally wanted to yell at my screen.
By the end, I realized I wasn't just watching a palace drama anymore.
I had become part of the investigation.
And perhaps the line that stayed with me most was Yingluo's answer to Qianlong:
“Regarding your question, I don't have an answer right now. But I will spend a lifetime answering you. Just be patient and wait.”
After spending 70 episodes watching these characters scheme, struggle, love, lose, adapt, and survive, that line felt like a beautiful way to end the journey.
Was this review helpful to you?
For the most part, the Thai version is better
The only thing I liked more in this adaptation was that the family played a much smaller role, since they annoyed me most in the Thai version. I also liked that, for once in a Japanese drama, things weren't exaggerated. This was one of the things I was most worried about because in the Thai version it's so over the top.I don't think this show needed to be longer episode-wise; maybe 10 minutes longer per episode & cut out most of the flashbacks. With that and the family taking up less screen time, they could have actually done something with the side couples. Don't introduce them if you aren't going to do anything with them! Giving the side couples an actual plot may have helped with the overall pacing, since after episode 2 it started to drag. I'm starting to wonder if the book even does anything with them. I'm curious, but not enough to subject myself to consuming this story in another form.
I don't have any complaints about the acting, but the fights looked really fake, and while the kisses were better than most Japanese series, the chemistry just wasn't there.
I still ended up watching the Thai and Japanese versions at X2 speed when my attention started to drift, so I can't say that I recommend either unless you've just started watching asian dramas.
Was this review helpful to you?
This review may contain spoilers
The narrative takes pleasure in revealing its stakes bit by bit; the pieces of the puzzle fall into place through the details, nothing is highlighted; conversations suggest that we know more than we let on. Everyone plays their part, and the heroine is a virtuoso amongst the orchestra’s soloists. (What on earth am I saying ?) She often takes us by surprise with her actions and the things she dares to say, and yet the story carries on, the music carries on ; let’s just carry on as if nothing had happened. I really like this approach, with its confidence and mastery. Perspectives shift ; we revisit a scene and gain a better understanding of the danger the heroine faces, a pawn in the service of the family she has just joined.As is the tradition with C-dramas, if it doesn’t grab you after five episodes, you should give up on it. In this case, I binge-watched the first eight as if my life depended on it.
The heroine stumbles upon a rather suspicious ally (Tan Rui/Xu Kai) who comes to bring down her family for corruption, and their enemy-to-lover romance is at first utterly delightful, then becomes thoroughly ambiguous. The two pursue their goals whilst skilfully concealing their true intentions; they use each other, yet they fall more and more in love, against all odds.
This is no smooth-sailing revenge; the price is a heavy one, and our duo are not without their flaws. Take the scene with the beatings in episode 4, for example. Or that loveless marriage in episode 23, inevitable, yet ending in tragedy. The violence amongst the women at the head of the Xie family plays out amidst terror and false displays of affection. The arrival of the head of the family does not change this dynamic but complicates it. This patriarch treads carefully, remaining silent at crucial moments, motionless as a statue. A very strange character. And the final revelation about him and the heroine’s mother is quite surprising, even though it was all right there in front of our eyes. When he loses his mind, alone in his vast estate, it’s surreal. I absolutely love these last two episodes, which dissect power and its temporal dimensions.
All these intrigues meet with a most cruel outcome. A patriarchal system that is inevitably destructive, and one supported by the women who benefit from it... until they, in turn, are sacrificed. A tale of filial piety. Some wish to abolish noble families and ‘clear away’ the powerful clans, we are told, but those concerned have no intention of giving an inch. All these stories of birth, family and inheritance are entirely fabricated. The grandmother, the true head of the Xie family, is very pleased with the harm she has caused others to secure her fine and respectable position. She shows no regret. Her tears are for having had to do what she had to do, and she would do it again if she had to. “But I pity you because you are the one who has been trapped in this house for the longest.”
Strangely enough, I watched Eight Hundred just before Spring of the Blade. Xu Kai pulls off quite a balancing act. Two ambiguous characters, each in their own way. One is all restraint, the other tempestuous. A fine actor, that’s for sure.
Zhou Ye is true to form in a role that’s cunning and authoritative, in a way. Her character commands respect through her dignity and her shrewd little tricks, which she uses to force the hidden truth into the open. She was already brilliant in Legend of the Female General, which was very different.
I hope to see these two together again. They’re a great match.
The colours are always stunning. Lots of pastels, washed-out pinks, jade shades and mauve, what impeccable taste ! There are some magnificent landscapes of hills and mountains at the start, but most of it takes place indoors. Sets built entirely for this shoot, at a time when slobbery, ugly AI-dramas abound. (The all-out AI shift that some C-dramas and films are taking really puts me off)
In the first few episodes, one track on the soundtrack draws a bit too heavily on Ravel’s Pavane, it really bothered me. After that, it doesn’t come back.
Was this review helpful to you?
I hate verticals
I really do hate vertical shorts they usually lack story and fail to hook me but this drama, man. The concept of the story was amazing, it had me absolutely hooked. Why did they make this a vertical? The story had so much potential and I would have loved to see it played out as a proper drama with more time for character depth and a more well played out ending. I’m being serious when I say this drama would have done numbers if it wasn’t a vertical.All this aside, genuinely surprised a short was able to grip me this hard and will definitely be giving other shorts more of a chance because it was an extremely enjoyable watch even if I have a few criticisms.
Was this review helpful to you?
